Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • 5 months later...
Guest Craig-NUFC

Kick It Out have created an app that lets fans at a match report discrimination that they hear.

 

The app, also launched today so fans can download it ahead of the new football season, is available to users on iPhone and Android devices. It was developed after a survey, carried out by Populus with over 5,000 fans, determined that more options were required to report discriminatory behaviour. The reporting of these incidents can be done anonymously, in order to protect those who fear they may be singled out if they are seen to be taking action.

http://www.kickitout.org/1575.php

 

Canny idea imo. Just hope people don't abuse it by taking the piss and make it obsolete.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest reefatoon

I watched "The Match Revisited" on Sunday morning and it was Man Utd V West Brom from 1979.  The abuse Regis and Cunningham were getting from the crowd was horrendous.  As a kid going to the matches in the 80's it was something I never really noticed as I was only young and watching the game, but christ, watching them back now just makes you cringe, it was shocking.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I watched "The Match Revisited" on Sunday morning and it was Man Utd V West Brom from 1979.  The abuse Regis and Cunningham were getting from the crowd was horrendous.  As a kid going to the matches in the 80's it was something I never really noticed as I was only young and watching the game, but christ, watching them back now just makes you cringe, it was shocking.

 

The only racist remarks I really remember at St James' towards one of our own players was someone calling Franz Carr a useless black bastard (the same guy was cheering with the rest of the crowd when Carr scored less than 30 seconds after that).  I think Carr was only the 5th black player to play for us so it might have just been that we'd never had enough black players prior to that for the racists to complain about, I did know someone whose wife used to call Asprilla that nig nog so there were definitely plenty of ignorant racists supporting us.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kick It Out have created an app that lets fans at a match report discrimination that they hear.

 

The app, also launched today so fans can download it ahead of the new football season, is available to users on iPhone and Android devices. It was developed after a survey, carried out by Populus with over 5,000 fans, determined that more options were required to report discriminatory behaviour. The reporting of these incidents can be done anonymously, in order to protect those who fear they may be singled out if they are seen to be taking action.

http://www.kickitout.org/1575.php

 

Canny idea imo. Just hope people don't abuse it by taking the p*ss and make it obsolete.

 

Shame you can't get a 3G signal inside SJP... :lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Phil K

Hooliganism on the continent is much more 'political' than over here, with Ultras aligning themselves as either Far Right/Facist/Anti-Communist and Far Left/Communist/Anti-Facist.  As well as the general anti-semitism towards Jews you find on the far-right, amongst facist football hooligans for some reason there's an assumption that all Jews are Communist sympathisers, and so the chance to stick the boot in to a perceived 'Jewish team' gives them the opportunity to cement their militant-political credentials.

Going by many PC types, I'd say the anti-semitism is AT LEAST as bad among the mis-named "socialists" (wonder who THEY'RE trying to impress....) I know - Ive argued on the subject with the pompous hypocrites.

This whole thing seems to have blown up again when it had all but died off. Wonder if it's been the attention and spotlight that has given it a new lease of life ?

You think the Suarez thing may have been fuel on the fire ? The Terry thing, and the Ferdinands making such a big deal of it actually made things worse ?

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...

I've just been watching Match of the Day and seen they're suggesting that Anelka was making anti-semitic gestures when he scored, the 'spurs fans have been pulled up for chanting "Yid Army", and there seems to constantly be at least one story doing the rounds about racism, just in English football.

 

I appreciate it is a sensitive subject, but some if it seems to be over the top, and a load of nonsense to be honest. Especially, when you turn away from racism and look at the abuse about Carroll being a Gypsy or whatever.

 

At what point do you draw the line, and will we slowly see the demise in 'banter' between fans?

Link to post
Share on other sites

If Anelka was making anti-semetic gestures then I imagine the line can be drawn far after that :lol:

 

Aye - I agree, haha.  :lol: :lol:

 

It's just if it was a gesture to a friend, like, a none-racist one, then the area becomes Grey for me. It's like theoretically Suarez kissing his wrist could be offensive to people. Dancing like a prick could be. Doing the machine-gun celebration could be. When a player does an aeroplane is that offensive to people who suffered 9/11? Like I'm sure you get where I am coming from. It's like the HSBC adverts of old...

Link to post
Share on other sites

I've just been watching Match of the Day and seen they're suggesting that Anelka was making anti-semitic gestures when he scored, the 'spurs fans have been pulled up for chanting "Yid Army", and there seems to constantly be at least one story doing the rounds about racism, just in English football.

 

I appreciate it is a sensitive subject, but some if it seems to be over the top, and a load of nonsense to be honest. Especially, when you turn away from racism and look at the abuse about Carroll being a Gypsy or whatever.

 

At what point do you draw the line, and will we slowly see the demise in 'banter' between fans?

 

There's a a big step between stopping anti-semetic chants and stopping banter. West Ham fans singing 'Hitler's coming for you' and making hissing noises is hardly banter and so they were rightly pulled up on it. Nobody wants to see the end of fan banter but the message needs to be that racism/anti-semetism is in no way acceptable.

 

edit: just seen your response and yeah I see your point. I still think there is a difference between things being just offensive and things being racist though.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm all for just stopping s*** banter all together tbh. I'd just as quickly kick the spuds out for that pathetically long and slow rendition of The Saints Go Marching In than I would the West Ham fans.

 

:lol: I'm all for having a patter police. Anyone caught singing 'he scores when he wants' should be banned from all grounds.

Link to post
Share on other sites

:lol:

 

There is some utter shite banter like at times too, which is dreadful but in a bizarre sense amusing, nevertheless. Purely for the WTF element.

 

Don't get me wrong, I am all for racism being stamped out, but I just think the line between banter and racism/abuse is getting a Greyer area with too many campaigns or groups trying to justify themselves rather than have a bit of sense.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't get me wrong, I am all for racism being stamped out, but I just think the line between banter and racism/abuse is getting a Greyer area with too many campaigns or groups trying to justify themselves rather than have a bit of sense.

 

Can you give an example?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't get me wrong, I am all for racism being stamped out, but I just think the line between banter and racism/abuse is getting a Greyer area with too many campaigns or groups trying to justify themselves rather than have a bit of sense.

 

Can you give an example?

 

Off the top of my head, you have the Steven Taylor incident.

You then have things like the Andy Carroll incident where they were saying he was a gypsy and one national reporter said it was racist or something.

Potentially, you have this Anelka incident.

 

There are probably a lot more but I cannot be arsed to find them all... :lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't get me wrong, I am all for racism being stamped out, but I just think the line between banter and racism/abuse is getting a Greyer area with too many campaigns or groups trying to justify themselves rather than have a bit of sense.

 

Can you give an example?

 

Off the top of my head, you have the Steven Taylor incident.

You then have things like the Andy Carroll incident where they were saying he was a gypsy and one national reporter said it was racist or something.

Potentially, you have this Anelka incident.

 

There are probably a lot more but I cannot be arsed to find them all... :lol:

 

Stephen Taylor was pure ignorance, but footballers with their massive public profile need to know better

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't get me wrong, I am all for racism being stamped out, but I just think the line between banter and racism/abuse is getting a Greyer area with too many campaigns or groups trying to justify themselves rather than have a bit of sense.

 

Can you give an example?

 

Off the top of my head, you have the Steven Taylor incident.

You then have things like the Andy Carroll incident where they were saying he was a gypsy and one national reporter said it was racist or something.

Potentially, you have this Anelka incident.

 

There are probably a lot more but I cannot be arsed to find them all... :lol:

 

Stephen Taylor was pure ignorance, but footballers with their massive public profile need to know better

 

Aye, they should no better. All I am getting at is to what degree though - like I wouldn't know what gestures might offend a Chinese person, or Italian, or whatever.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't get me wrong, I am all for racism being stamped out, but I just think the line between banter and racism/abuse is getting a Greyer area with too many campaigns or groups trying to justify themselves rather than have a bit of sense.

 

Can you give an example?

 

Off the top of my head, you have the Steven Taylor incident.

You then have things like the Andy Carroll incident where they were saying he was a gypsy and one national reporter said it was racist or something.

Potentially, you have this Anelka incident.

 

There are probably a lot more but I cannot be arsed to find them all... :lol:

 

Stephen Taylor was pure ignorance, but footballers with their massive public profile need to know better

 

Aye, they should no better. All I am getting at is to what degree though - like I wouldn't know what gestures might offend a Chinese person, or Italian, or whatever.

 

Fair enough, I Would agree, but say if an english player had made the gesture Anelka did, I think it would be unreasonable to expect him to know that was an anti-Semitic gesture  in France and wouldn't expect him to be punished for it, but he is going to be under scrutiny in his own country and is a part, however small, of representing the premier league brand in France and as much as I hate the idea of 'advertising' the league, one aspect I'd Like to see represented is our inclusive nature regardless of race/colour/religion.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't get me wrong, I am all for racism being stamped out, but I just think the line between banter and racism/abuse is getting a Greyer area with too many campaigns or groups trying to justify themselves rather than have a bit of sense.

 

Can you give an example?

 

Off the top of my head, you have the Steven Taylor incident.

You then have things like the Andy Carroll incident where they were saying he was a gypsy and one national reporter said it was racist or something.

Potentially, you have this Anelka incident.

 

There are probably a lot more but I cannot be arsed to find them all... :lol:

 

Stephen Taylor was pure ignorance, but footballers with their massive public profile need to know better

 

Aye, they should no better. All I am getting at is to what degree though - like I wouldn't know what gestures might offend a Chinese person, or Italian, or whatever.

 

Fair enough, I Would agree, but say if an english player had made the gesture Anelka did, I think it would be unreasonable to expect him to know that was an anti-Semitic gesture  in France and wouldn't expect him to be punished for it, but he is going to be under scrutiny in his own country and is a part, however small, of representing the premier league brand in France and as much as I hate the idea of 'advertising' the league, one aspect I'd Like to see represented is our inclusive nature regardless of race/colour/religion.

 

Aye, I see where you're coming from like. To be fair though, there could be 'new' gestures or insults kicking about in the UK that I wouldn't know about, so to a point it is unreasonable to assume Anelka knows every offensive gesture or insult in France, especially saying as France is like twice the size.

 

I do agree in that, we want the Premier League to show it is all inclusive as you said, however.

 

Ultimately, there is no way of proving what he meant by it, and he will and probably should get off with a slap on the wrist.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...