The fight and scrap argument really is lazy PFM bullshit: Put to one side and ignore any actual footballing ability you may have, and just get out there and fight.
What does "fight" even mean nowadays in football?
It's the sort of mentality that has seen us take the field and get thrashed left right and centre by any team who fancied passing the ball. Including our local rivals.
The irony being that when fight and scrap was meant to be a focal point (like most of Pardew's lineups), the players had very little fight in them.
When we ended up run away winners of the Championship in 2010 we certainly didn't do it by fighting and scrapping.