Graham Carr

[Mole_Toonfan]

He can 'spot a player' my left nut, like. f***ing Stifler from here could've recommended Cabaye and Ben Arfa. Every time his scouting abilities have actually been put to the test we've signed utter rubbish or players not right for the PL.

 

Except hardly any of us knew who Cabaye was when we signed him and don't lie.

 

I mean any scout who watched him probably would have noticed him but please not let's act like he was a world renowned name.

 

There's been plenty of other great players like Aubameyang among others that he advised we get but Ashley never put the cash down.

 

Sure there's been a lot of duds but let's not act like the only good players he's put forward to the club have been Cabaye or Ben Arfa.

[HawK]

I think HBA scouted himself tbf

[Mole_Toonfan]

Aye I don't give him credit for HBA, any nutcase could have seen that one.

[Toondave]

Think it's rather difficult to judge him without knowing exactly what say he has had, or what weighting he's put on the players we've ended up signing. I think it's pretty clear he's ended up in a role not best suited to him however but that seems to have been reverted now?

 

If Rafa is okay with what he's doing, and has the ultimate say, then let's go with it.

[junkhead]

He deserves his 8 year contract just for giving us the opportunity to w*** over Ben Arfa's genuis. At the same time the Cabella and Thauvin deals and subsequent loans were dodgy as f***. It's like he acted on behalf of agents and Marseille. And let's not get into the Doumbia and Ferreyra loans.. Still I have no problem with him staying on as long as it's Benitez having the final say.

 

 

[BlueStar]

Think it's rather difficult to judge him without knowing exactly what say he has had, or what weighting he's put on the players we've ended up signing.

 

Wasn't there a report saying he'd offered his resignation, but it was refused on the grounds that we hadn't manage to buy any of his first choice targets?

[Disco]

Wild celebrations in the Mondial Sport office.

[Hanshithispantz]

He can 'spot a player' my left nut, like. f***ing Stifler from here could've recommended Cabaye and Ben Arfa. Every time his scouting abilities have actually been put to the test we've signed utter rubbish or players not right for the PL.

 

Except hardly any of us knew who Cabaye was when we signed him and don't lie.

 

I mean any scout who watched him probably would have noticed him but please not let's act like he was a world renowned name.

 

There's been plenty of other great players like Aubameyang among others that he advised we get but Ashley never put the cash down.

 

Sure there's been a lot of duds but let's not act like the only good players he's put forward to the club have been Cabaye or Ben Arfa.

I'm sure anyone who followed Ligue 1 knew who Cabaye was like. He was regarded as on of the best players for the French champions. I don't watch that league, but if I did I'd know who he was for sure, it's pretty much like someone recommending Kante*.

 

Getting him for so cheap without anyone else activating his clause was impressive, but in hindsight it seems more luck than anything, same with Ba.

 

*Spotting him a couple of years ago is different, that's actually good scouting.

 

 

[Shays Given Tim Flowers]

Nothing to do with luck, everything to do with moving money around.

[Foluwashola]

All he's ever been is a scout. Was given God-like status and then shot down, it's the English way. Was happy to see him go as our scouting policy clearly hasn't worked of late, but if he can work with Rafa there's no issue.

[arnonel]

A) There is no such thing as the perfect scout. Its not an exact science

B) Doesnt matter if you are the best scout in the world, if the manager is crap - no player is good enough. (Ben Arfa)

 

I have no problem keeping Carr, but having someone like Rafa as the filter - instead of Kinnear/Pardew/Charnley/et al

[Guest]

He can 'spot a player' my left nut, like. f***ing Stifler from here could've recommended Cabaye and Ben Arfa. Every time his scouting abilities have actually been put to the test we've signed utter rubbish or players not right for the PL.

 

Except hardly any of us knew who Cabaye was when we signed him and don't lie.

 

I mean any scout who watched him probably would have noticed him but please not let's act like he was a world renowned name.

 

There's been plenty of other great players like Aubameyang among others that he advised we get but Ashley never put the cash down.

 

Sure there's been a lot of duds but let's not act like the only good players he's put forward to the club have been Cabaye or Ben Arfa.

 

Gameiro, Matuidi, Payet, Aubameyang, Cabaye...all before they were considered 'elite'.

[Hanshithispantz]

All he's ever been is a scout. Was given God-like status and then shot down, it's the English way. Was happy to see him go as our scouting policy clearly hasn't worked of late, but if he can work with Rafa there's no issue.

What you mean? He was/is part of the board.

[Kanj]

I wanted him gone but if Rafa is cool with it so am I

[HawK]

I wanted him gone but if Rafa is cool with it so am I

 

I get this argument to some degree, but there must be some exceptions

[Kanj]

Naw. No way. Trust our man 100%.

 

Still wish the old kernt would retire but whatever. I'm sure he will sooner than later.

[HawK]

Would love more Darth Vader / Graham Carr images personally. The resemblance on the one Dave posted was absolutely uncanny.

[54]

There is more opinion changing going on in here than a Hillary Clinton rally.

[Dr Venkman]

There is more opinion changing going on in here than a Hillary Clinton rally.

 

Quotes

[Stottie]

According to the player himself, we went as far as offering Aubameyang higher wages but he chose Dortmund.

[Guest]

Bony was another one.

[loki679]

Have no issue with Carr being on board.

 

I think its hard to judge his track record as i am lead to believe the power at NUFC have not been picking his top picks, but went far down the list for the cheapest options.

 

I think he can be a good asset to Rafa, in a environment where the manager has the final say in transfers.

 

I get the list thing but it kind of falls down a bit when Riviere is somehow on a list not titled 'Fucking wank players we should never ever think about signing'.

 

I mean, was it a list of good players or just a list of players?  i'd have second thoughts about including Gouffran in the phone book.

[Guest Howaythetoon]

He wants to fucking retire simply for putting forward his mate McClaren for the job.

[relámpago blanco]

Have no issue with Carr being on board.

 

I think its hard to judge his track record as i am lead to believe the power at NUFC have not been picking his top picks, but went far down the list for the cheapest options.

 

I think he can be a good asset to Rafa, in a environment where the manager has the final say in transfers.

 

I get the list thing but it kind of falls down a bit when Riviere is somehow on a list not titled 'Fucking wank players we should never ever think about signing'.

 

I mean, was it a list of good players or just a list of players?  i'd have second thoughts about including Gouffran in the phone book.

I forgot about Riviere. I wonder what hell be like in the Championship. Shite most likely but you never know.

[Guest antz1uk]

He wants to f***ing retire simply for putting forward his mate McClaren for the job.