Jump to content

Recommended Posts

6 minutes ago, HTT II said:

Again why do people keep posting the same regurgitated shit from these know nowt journos/Twitter accounts? Baffles me!

It’s a transfer rumour in the transfer rumour thread 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest HTT II
Just now, SUPERTOON said:

It’s a transfer rumour in the transfer rumour thread 

I know, but it’s so tenuous. I can make up the same shit on Twitter. It’s easy. Means fuck all.

Link to post
Share on other sites

https://theathletic.com/3380360/2022/06/24/jonathan-david-transfers/

I've clipped our bit featuring Caulkin. 

Quote

Newcastle United (11th place last season)


What do you get when you mix a young, highly-touted, goal-scoring forward with a club suddenly able to spend big? The perfect mix for a transfer rumour cocktail.

 

With the addition of Bruno Guimaraes from Lyon, it seems like the club are intent on using the new cash this summer.

 

In theory, a move to Newcastle could work for David: he’d get to challenge himself in the Premier League and do so on a team that might not have the competition for starting spots that some of the other teams on this list do.

 

George Caulkin’s take: This feels more like a case of club plus new money plus available player equals easy story than anything vastly more substantive. Certainly at the moment. Newcastle have been in the hunt for a new striker for a while and Everton’s Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Ivan Toney featured in discussions, but the strong form of Callum Wilson after a long lay-off through injury towards the end of last season blurred priorities. If Wilson can stay fit he is as good as anybody and Calvert-Lewin and Toney would be expensive. And funds are an issue, in spite of Newcastle’s Saudi-led takeover, with Financial Fair Play expected to cap their spending this summer to somewhere between £60-80 million this summer, potentially a little more if a special player becomes available.


Newcastle appear to be focusing their spending elsewhere, including on 20-year-old Reims forward Hugo Ekitike and 22-year-old Lille defender Sven Botman.

 

Tactically, David wouldn’t necessarily be the best fit at Newcastle. Manager Eddie Howe often plays with a front three, and the spots at the top of the three are usually occupied by Callum Wilson or Chris Wood, with his other forwards usually playing in wider roles that David isn’t always accustomed to.

 

So, should Newcastle shift their spending focus towards David?

 

Caulkin: Newcastle need reinforcements and they need upgrades. David would tick both of those boxes. Whether he is what they need right now at the price he would cost, is less obvious. 


Would rather David than Ekitike, as I'm massively biased. :lol: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I want Gouiri. Because this means that CW can start and when/if he is injured Gouiri can play centrally too. Get Gouiri and a high quality right sided forward/winger. When Wilson is fit we would then have 3 very good options for our wide positions to alternate between. With Miggy and Fraser as backup to these three wide players. Ideally another CF if the money and right option is available obviously. 
 

Gouiri goes to to a team in one of the top leagues then I’m pretty sure that already after a season he will be a 50-60m plus player. 

 

 

Edited by Ikon

Link to post
Share on other sites

Going this route would buy us some time to get another centre forward later on. Then we could push for other areas before we maybe go for another CF. Would be a good start 

 

He's too talented and technically good so I just can’t see him fail.

 

 

Edited by Ikon

Link to post
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, The Bonk said:

https://theathletic.com/3380360/2022/06/24/jonathan-david-transfers/

I've clipped our bit featuring Caulkin. 


Would rather David than Ekitike, as I'm massively biased. :lol: 

Going by that, If we do end up with botman & Etikite there won’t be much money left for much else. That would be quite disappointing imo 

 

 

Edited by gdm

Link to post
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, nufc123 said:

We wont go the same run we had after christmas. At the same time we wont have as little as we had before christmas. But the team is not a top 7 team. We are lacking badly up front bar Wilson. And he will be out for some time in a season. We need pace in defence. We need legs in the midfield. We need a wide man capable of more than 1 and 2 goals under their belt. The wide area is shocking. Take away Maximin and its almost not Pl worthy. And we need a backup for Wilson. After that we can be taken seriously in the top 7 race.


Agreed. Even a fair coin can flip heads 7 times in a row. Our expected points last seasons is actually 41.53, but we ended up with 49 points. That says we were a bit lucky, and there is no guarantee this would repeat next season. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, gdm said:

Going by that, If we do end up with botman & Etikite there won’t be much money left for much else 

 

I think Ekitike is going to be a loan-to-buy job, with much of the fee therefore delayed until next summer. Reims are a relatively small club (not historically - but right now financially) so are probably more open to structured deals like this. 

It might be why we're so committed to his signing over other options. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

26 minutes ago, SUPERTOON said:

Sounds like they have fallen in to the same trap of believing Wilson can stay fit all season 

I refuse to believe that a couple of excellent games from Wilson 'blurs thinking' over longer term transfer strategies like. The transfer team that's being set up will be well aware of what needs to be done.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just comparing Ekitike and Broja on FBRef; goals, attacking performance, passing dribbling... Ekitike is more effective hands down, despite playing less football last season. Broja only beats him on pressing. Gouiri compares a lot better. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, The Bonk said:

https://theathletic.com/3380360/2022/06/24/jonathan-david-transfers/

I've clipped our bit featuring Caulkin. 


Would rather David than Ekitike, as I'm massively biased. :lol: 

Both would be super ?

Very different players. I think David could play behind Calum or replace him. His stock has probably cooled a little too. Howe would be great for him though. If I have one criticism with David it's his work rate. I think that's due to the role he has been given rather than ability to do so. Lille were also the masters of not passing to him for the longest time. It's a miracle he scored as many as he did to this point.

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, toontownman said:

Both would be super ?

Very different players. I think David could play behind Calum or replace him. His stock has probably cooled a little too. Howe would be great for him though. If I have one criticism with David it's his work rate. I think that's due to the role he has been given rather than ability to do so. Lille were also the masters of not passing to him for the longest time. It's a miracle he scored as many as he did to this point.

 

Needs to work on his composure as well, find David can be very reactive and fighting the ball even in low pressure situations.

Link to post
Share on other sites

As I continue to pop in here for updates, I think I've come to a strange realisation that I'm not that excited about this transfer window.

 

Ive been so detached from the wider footballing landscape the last few years that I don't know who the fuck any of our rumoured targets are. So I wouldn't know who/what I'm getting excited over. :lol:

 

Shame really. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...