Newcastle United 3-0 Aston Villa - 26/12/24

[healthyaddiction]

1 minute ago, huss9 said:

had never heard of morgan rogers prior to this season.

was he just as good at boro?

signing of the season?

They bought him last season.

[LFEE]

1 minute ago, huss9 said:

had never heard of morgan rogers prior to this season.

was he just as good at boro?

signing of the season?

Was impressed with him. Great signing.

[huss9]

was relieved when they subbed him off.

if they'd managed to grab a goal, we would have shat ourselves.

i wasnt able to relax till our third.

PTSD.

[DahnSahf]

4 hours ago, Lush Vlad said:

He was very unfortunate. He tried to miss him on 3 separate occasions by moving his legs in Schar’s direction.  

 

Maybe he watches a lot of Indycar? They reckon you should aim for the car spinning ahead of you 'cause by the time you get there it'll be somewhere else.

[mikejaxer]

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11661/13280444/ref-watch-aston-villas-jhon-duran-right-to-be-shown-red-card-vs-newcastle-says-dermot-gallagher

 

Correctly shown a red according to Ref Watch

[RodneyCisse]

I can’t believe how many think it was accidental (outside this forum) I was worried the ref would lose his bottle and not do the right thing.

[huss9]

its the change in direction of the right foot.

would have been easier just to plant it on the turf.

dermot gallagher mentions it but the presenter's having none of it.

 

nee chance they appeal it.

[Checko]

4 hours ago, Hanshithispantz said:

What is the actual rule?

 

That's never a penalty at the other end. Accidental handballs with your arm by our side will be disallowed if it goes straight in, but will stand if it was going wide and was deflected in?

Basically, if it hits your arm it's handball if it's one of these situations:

 

1. Deliberate handball, e.g  hand to ball.

 

2. Accidental but your arm was in a position that made your body unnaturally bigger. (Basically is your arm position reasonable taking into account your movement) - Judgement call, eg Tino vs PSG

 

3. Accidental but it goes in off your arm, even if just a tiny brush (what Bruno was penalised for)

 

4. Accidental and you yourself score immediately after it hits your arm. (Eg Wilson vs Brentford away a year or two ago)

 

If it hits your arm accidentally someone else can score immediately, (eg Longstaff's goal vs fulham last year here) but you can't score yourself. So in this case, it hit Bruno's arm, so he couldn't score, but someone else could. As it looks as if it would be going wide without the deflection it would be an own goal, so none of the above categories apply.

 

EDIT: That said, watching the highlights, from another angle I can't actually tell for sure whether it was going in off Bruno or not.

 

 

Edited 16 hours ago by Checko

[Doug]

Fox in the henhouse time for Doug as I currently live 20 miles from Villa park

[astraguy]

On what page has brummie posted on? I still think that onana signing is shocking considering his the clubs  biggest fee? like that other dude who went after one season

[Stifler]

16 minutes ago, astraguy said:

On what page has brummie posted on? I still think that onana signing is shocking considering his the clubs  biggest fee? like that other dude who went after one season

Diaby?

[PauloGeordio]

 

[Dr. TC]

2 minutes ago, PauloGeordio said:

 

I don't understand how this didn't get more prominence as simulation 

[PauloGeordio]

8 minutes ago, Dr. TC said:

I don't understand how this didn't get more prominence as simulation 

Yes he embarrassed himself with that! 

 

 

Edited 14 hours ago by PauloGeordio

[Skeletor]

There were people actually arguing that it was a correct decision to give him a yellow. Morgan should join Brereton Diaz in the failed cunt brigade. They could use VAR for good by dishing out reds to those who simulate like that.

 

 

Edited 14 hours ago by Skeletor

[gazza ladra]

That's Brereton Diaz-level shithousery.

 

I think there was more commentary on Schär and the "dark arts" than on Rogers'  simulation. 

 

"Oh, look Schär's holding onto his shirt behind his back. Out of sight of the referee. Very clever..."

 

Edit: see that Skeletor beat me out on bringing up that Southampton bastard. (Schär must drive opponents out of their minds.)

 

 

 

 

Edited 14 hours ago by gazza ladra

[RodneyCisse]

4 hours ago, huss9 said:

its the change in direction of the right foot.

would have been easier just to plant it on the turf.

dermot gallagher mentions it but the presenter's having none of it.

 

nee chance they appeal it.

They should to get the ban extended.

 

Makes Schars at the start of the season even more laughable.

[David Edgar]

It was Morgan who let Murphy go free for our second. Morgan did not cover himself in glory yesterday.

[Alberto2005]

Is there a video out of the proper post match press conference with all the journos for this?

[STM]

6 minutes ago, Alberto2005 said:

Is there a video out of the proper post match press conference with all the journos for this?

Try beanyman sports on YouTube.

[STM]

Na couldn't find it.

[Turnbull2000]

 

[Astroblack]

^ Looks more and more intentional from the behind the scenes vid. 

[Ikon]

Loco appeal turned down. 3 match ban stands.

 

 

 

 

Edited 12 hours ago by Ikon

[Fak]

14 minutes ago, Turnbull2000 said:

 

where’s the HT brawl?