Jump to content
Newcastle-Online

West Brom 3 - 1 Newcastle United - 05/12/10 - post match reaction from page 38

Dave

by Dave
in Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

Neil

Neil

Posted
Posted

I must be missing something here. What did Enrique do to deserve such a high rating? Yes he's a good player, and he's far from your biggest problem, but he was well below-par today. Or can Enrique not have a bad game?

 

Tiote was the only decent player for me today. Enrique dwelled on the ball a hell of a lot today and gave it away loads too. He was actually very frustrating a lot of the time. So no, I wasn't impressed either.

 

Yep. :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites
Minhosa

Minhosa

Posted
Posted

Well some of your predictions were a bit optomistic (0-6), thought Cambell looked an absolute liability, apart from Carrolls hand ball assist, he did nothing, I'm sure you will be okay though, funny old division this Premiership. :celb:

 

You were hardly Brazil and caught us on a particularly bad off day, missing key players.

 

We'll beat you at our place with a couple of players back.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest firetotheworks

Guest firetotheworks

Posted
Posted

Krul 5

Simpson 6

Taylor 5

Campbell 5

Enrique 7

Jonas 5

Guthrie 2

Tiote 4

Routledge 4

Carroll 4

Ameobi 3

 

Lovenkrands 5

Ranger 5

 

On this planet what marks would they get?

 

Tiote a 4 the rest 1 (for turning up)

 

I trust we'll be seeing more of you now we've lost? What with you being a maudlin prostitute and all.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Segun Oluwaniyi

Segun Oluwaniyi

Posted
Posted

It's a bit scary if West Ham win this morning (as I expect them to). West Brom have shown no signs of collapse and seem a rather solid Premiership team. West Ham seem to have found a formula that works and I personally expect them to improve and get results as long as the forward line and Parker stay healthy. Wigan are gone, imo, but who will go with them?

Link to post
Share on other sites
Kaizero

Kaizero

Posted
Posted

It's a bit scary if West Ham win this morning (as I expect them to). West Brom have shown no signs of collapse and seem a rather solid Premiership team. West Ham seem to have found a formula that works and I personally expect them to improve and get results as long as the forward line and Parker stay healthy. Wigan are gone, imo, but who will go with them?

 

Wolves.

Link to post
Share on other sites
zolton

zolton

Posted
Posted

Well some of your predictions were a bit optomistic (0-6), thought Cambell looked an absolute liability, apart from Carrolls hand ball assist, he did nothing, I'm sure you will be okay though, funny old division this Premiership. :celb:

 

You were hardly Brazil and caught us on a particularly bad off day, missing key players.

 

We'll beat you at our place with a couple of players back.

 

Probably will, sometimes you have days like that, we have had one or two.

Link to post
Share on other sites
GM

GM

Posted
Posted

krul - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

simpson - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

campbell  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

taylor  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

enrique  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

routledge  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

guthrie - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

tiote  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

jonas  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

Shola - fuck off

Carroll  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

 

Loven  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

Smith  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

Ranger  - http://imgur.com/ZEQLW.gif

 

:lol: I like this new scoring index.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest BooBoo

Guest BooBoo

Posted
Posted

We cant keep relying on the sort of mega performances like Villa, Arsenal and the Mackems. Unless you're a top side, those days only come along a handful times every season. Its worrying that we seem incapable of playing "fairly well" and getting a good result. West Ham perhaps is the only example we've had this year where we've took the points without firing on every last cylinder.

 

In addition, at the start of the season we always looked fired up for the games and even the games we lost, i could take positives and heart from the effort. That's gone south though in the two last aways which have seen pathetic levels of heart and we've looked a beaten side from the moment we've fallen behind. Its very reminiscent of 08/09 and it has to be more than leaders like Nolan and Barton being forcibly replaced by the pea hearted Routledge and Guthrie.

 

I can understand Ashley's stubborn stance on the Hughton contract issue, he's showing he's very weak at changing a game when things aren't going our way. Nice to see Lovenkrands get his goal but we required a bit more physical presence and over the second 45 minutes, Ranger or Best would have been a stronger option.

 

A desperate day and another black mark against Hughton. Coming so soon after the Bolton debacle, he should be feeling the mounting pressure. Its quite easy to see that a tough winter could be on the cards.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Ameritoon

Ameritoon

Posted
Posted

I must be missing something here. What did Enrique do to deserve such a high rating? Yes he's a good player, and he's far from your biggest problem, but he was well below-par today. Or can Enrique not have a bad game?

 

Tiote was the only decent player for me today. Enrique dwelled on the ball a hell of a lot today and gave it away loads too. He was actually very frustrating a lot of the time. So no, I wasn't impressed either.

 

I only saw Enrique get beat once, a very good game defensively for him.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Big Geordie

Big Geordie

Posted
Posted

Well, that was garbage. We never got going and WBA were very easily able to pass our way around our midfield, which was over-ran. Tiote cannot do the job of two men as he tried to do for Guthrie today (who is just too slow and lightweight for this league) No win in 5 for us now which in itself is worrying, with Liverpool up next week. We need some new bodies in, in January - a creative/pacy MC is a must.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Nobody

Nobody

Posted
Posted

People giving Jonas 5 are being too generous.

As bad as anyone today. Guthrie is going to get the most shit, but Jonas and Campbell deserves just as much. They were complete and utter wank the lot of them.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest firetotheworks

Guest firetotheworks

Posted
Posted

Krul 5

Simpson 6

Taylor 5

Campbell 5

Enrique 7

Jonas 5

Guthrie 2

Tiote 4

Routledge 4

Carroll 4

Ameobi 3

 

Lovenkrands 5

Ranger 5

 

I'd agree with that apart from Tiote who I'd give a 6.

 

He was where he was supposed to be, doing what he was supposed to do, but there was just no one for him to pass to who wasn't within a 10m radius of him.

 

All in all, really depressing stuff. Really embarrassing making such an average WBA side look so good. Can't wait for Nolan, Barton, Colo and Williamson to get back. :(

 

Tbh, I thought Tiote was poor. He wasn't helped by the even poorer Guthrie, but in general I thought his, along with all of the midfield and attacks pressing was shocking. WBA played at a walking pace and we just seemed to be all 'ah right, no bother' about it. The team that went to Arsenal, West Ham and even Wolves would have beaten them today. The worrying thing for me is not only that we didn't turn up, but that we didn't seem to care that we hadn't turn up, there wasn't even any fight.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Skeletor

Skeletor

Posted
Posted

Krul - 5 - Couldn't have done much with the goals. One terrible flappy moment from a corner.

Simpson - 4 - Reminded me of the shocker he had last time against Thomas

Campbell - 4 - Looks about 80 years old on this showing. Horrible clearances time and time again.

Taylor - 4 - Captain idiot again

Enrique - 4 - Was doing alright until he got booked then it all went down hill.

Routledge - 3 - Standard premiership non-show from him.

Jonas - 4 - Extra point for kicking that microphone.

Guthrie - -10 - Kill yourself

Tiote - 6 - Only one really trying hard

Carroll - 3 - Terrible game

Ameobi - 0 - Should also kill himself

 

Lovenkrands - 6 - A better showing than usual and at least saved us a tiny bit of pride

Ranger - 5 - Did what none of our front players did all day and actually pressed and chased.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...