Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Really didn't expect this.

 

Hoping he can rediscover his old form, playing in less of a hoofball team would help him so hopefully McClaren is committed to that.

 

Sadly I think that this time next year we'll be wishing we'd got rid and brought in a replacement while we had the chance.

Link to post
Share on other sites

McClaren is right like, that statement Pardew put out was transparent as f***.

 

No, no, no.  It was all an elaborate scam set up by Coloccini's agent and backed by Pardew and the whole of Crystal Palace's opperational staff in order for Coloccini to be able to negotiate a contract extension on his terms.  There was no interest from Palace, it was all a lie.  You big deluded Geordie.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Really didn't expect this.

 

Hoping he can rediscover his old form, playing in less of a hoofball team would help him so hopefully McClaren is committed to that.

 

Sadly I think that this time next year we'll be wishing we'd got rid and brought in a replacement while we had the chance.

 

In theory if we do play less direct it should help him, but that's all it is at the moment sadly a theory.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Possession isn't going to make a teams defensive organisation or individuals any better.

 

Our 2 biggest defeats last year. Was it Leicester & Soton? Wasn't the result of incessant pressure. Just woeful, woeful, defending from the team.

 

and how was our attacking play, ball retention, passing through midfield, getting behind their defence to worry them etc. in those games oh wise one? 

 

why are you making out like it's not all linked? :lol:

 

of i course i agree that we're littered with examples of rank bad defending and shit defenders who were badly organised, but why can't you just accept that an improved possession and passing game with real attacking intent might relieve the pressure on a defence through them not having to defend their box incessantly every fucking game?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Defies belief that the club have retained Coloccini and decided to skimp on replacing him adequately - Colo's pace has definitely gone and opposition managers will play on this right throughout the season. Retaining him for a year as a STANDBY, after buying a top class replacement would have been justified...but we all know this aint going to happen...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Defies belief that the club have retained Coloccini and decided to skimp on replacing him adequately - Colo's pace has definitely gone and opposition managers will play on this right throughout the season. Retaining him for a year as a STANDBY, after buying a top class replacement would have been justified...but we all know this aint going to happen...

 

noooooot really

Link to post
Share on other sites

The fact that some are saying that playing alongside a 20 year old (ha) defender who is new to this country and to this league may give Colo a new lease of life after having been obviously past his best for the past three years tells me everything I need to know about how awful this decision is.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not convinced he is physically deteriorating TBH, at least not noticeably. His decline has been mainly mental, still think it's possible he can turn it round in the short term.

 

Almost everyone has looked shit for the last three years mind.

 

:thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

What I'm saying is Mbemba will need time to settle in under the guidance of a more experienced partner who can compensate a little bit for his deficiencies and help him get to grips with the toughest, most unforgiving football league a young defender could play in. Some make it sound like he will be the rock thay Colo can latch on to give him a new lease of life.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Defies belief that the club have retained Coloccini and decided to skimp on replacing him adequately - Colo's pace has definitely gone and opposition managers will play on this right throughout the season. Retaining him for a year as a STANDBY, after buying a top class replacement would have been justified...but we all know this aint going to happen...

 

I don't think he was ever that pacey to begin with. I agree with Ian that the physical decline is exaggerated. He looks basically the same player as when he arrived and he got plenty of stick then too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The fact that some are saying that playing alongside a 20 year old (ha) defender who is new to this country and to this league may give Colo a new lease of life after having been obviously past his best for the past three years tells me everything I need to know about how awful this decision is.

Tells you everything you need to know about NO logic.

 

A man is turning 34 in 5 months and some are saying he isn't physically deteriorating.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Defies belief that the club have retained Coloccini and decided to skimp on replacing him adequately - Colo's pace has definitely gone and opposition managers will play on this right throughout the season. Retaining him for a year as a STANDBY, after buying a top class replacement would have been justified...but we all know this aint going to happen...

 

I don't think he was ever that pacey to begin with. I agree with Ian that the physical decline is exaggerated. He looks basically the same player as when he arrived and he got plenty of stick then too.

 

But he's not though. He's that bit slower. He has to think that bit faster. His leap is that bit shorter and he hasn't compensated with other developments.

 

The pace and strength of the league is starting to get ahead of him again and this time he lacks the tools to adapt.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Defies belief that the club have retained Coloccini and decided to skimp on replacing him adequately - Colo's pace has definitely gone and opposition managers will play on this right throughout the season. Retaining him for a year as a STANDBY, after buying a top class replacement would have been justified...but we all know this aint going to happen...

 

noooooot really

You're right - it DOESN'T defy belief....this is Ashley's NUFC after all.....

Link to post
Share on other sites

What I'm saying is Mbemba will need time to settle in under the guidance of a more experienced partner who can compensate a little bit for his deficiencies and help him get to grips with the toughest, most unforgiving football league a young defender could play in. Some make it sound like he will be the rock thay Colo can latch on to give him a new lease of life.

 

Its not neccesarily a case of Mbemba being the rock Coloccini can latch on to.  But rather simply that Mbemba's attributes (pace, strength, aggression and a decent leap) should help to compensate for Coloccini's deficiencies in those area's and perhaps give him a better chance to focus on his game.  As opposed to when he's playing next to Williamson who has all the same deficiencies as Coloccini and then some.  Which leaves him having to try to cover for everything and coming up short.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...