Jump to content

Paul Dummett


Recommended Posts

Haidara's mistakes cost us goals. Dummett is safety first, which might increase pressure but doesn't directly lead to goals.

 

Don't see Haidara getting back in the team anyway. Think Dummett's relatively strong aerial ability compared to the rest of our team in defensive set-pieces is a massive reason he's in the team. Gets his head on the end of a lot of defensive corners.

Even if you fused them together to make a 'superplayer' he'd still be fairly s***.

 

If PD could run he'd be a very handy CB. But at LB I agree. Neither are good enough technically.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Haidara's mistakes cost us goals. Dummett is safety first, which might increase pressure but doesn't directly lead to goals.

 

Don't see Haidara getting back in the team anyway. Think Dummett's relatively strong aerial ability compared to the rest of our team in defensive set-pieces is a massive reason he's in the team. Gets his head on the end of a lot of defensive corners.

Even if you fused them together to make a 'superplayer' he'd still be fairly s***.

 

If PD could run he'd be a very handy CB. But at LB I agree. Neither are good enough technically.

 

Fair summation. I suppose the best way is to rotate them depending on the match situation. Neither one is clearly a cut above the other. Mbabu has played better than both by some distance, but he's so young and inexperienced, we haven't seen how bad he could be when he's not on it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd normally say Dummet was an upgrade on haidara but he was awful on saturday. Everything he did was nullified or opened us up to attacks.

I would get Mbabu in for the next one, we will need some pace, also worried about colo...

Link to post
Share on other sites

We looked best with Mbabu at LB anyway. Id rather him there until we sign a long term left back. I'd also like to see Mbabu be our backup RB for he future. He actually looks a real talent.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Haidara's mistakes cost us goals. Dummett is safety first, which might increase pressure but doesn't directly lead to goals.

 

Don't see Haidara getting back in the team anyway. Think Dummett's relatively strong aerial ability compared to the rest of our team in defensive set-pieces is a massive reason he's in the team. Gets his head on the end of a lot of defensive corners.

Even if you fused them together to make a 'superplayer' he'd still be fairly s***.

 

If PD could run he'd be a very handy CB. But at LB I agree. Neither are good enough technically.

 

Dummett could easily have cost us goals as well this season, many times he's been bailed out by Colo or weak finishing like on Saturday. Last season Dummett at least looked fairly solid defensively, this season his defending has been rubbish.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's a good point to mention PD has basically been chucked in the first team as soon as he's come back from an injury, with a limited pre-season as well. At his best he will be solid defensively while giving us nothing going the other way. I prefer that to Haidara.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Haidara's mistakes cost us goals. Dummett is safety first, which might increase pressure but doesn't directly lead to goals.

 

Don't see Haidara getting back in the team anyway. Think Dummett's relatively strong aerial ability compared to the rest of our team in defensive set-pieces is a massive reason he's in the team. Gets his head on the end of a lot of defensive corners.

Even if you fused them together to make a 'superplayer' he'd still be fairly s***.

 

If PD could run he'd be a very handy CB. But at LB I agree. Neither are good enough technically.

 

Dummett could easily have cost us goals as well this season, many times he's been bailed out by Colo or weak finishing like on Saturday. Last season Dummett at least looked fairly solid defensively, this season his defending has been rubbish.

 

Okay but Haidara has cost us actual goals.... he makes those kind of mistakes, no coming back mistakes.

 

Dummett's been poor since coming back from injury but he's better than Haidara.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

it was either the end of the first half or the beginning of the 2nd when I finally realised he was playing today. He stayed in a position more like LM, except of course when the ball was in that area and then he went missing into the middle of midfield. He was an absolute ghost today.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...