Jump to content

Recommended Posts

At the end of the day, at Montpellier, he played as a central attacking midfielder, playing quick passes, and playing one twos, rarely going shoulder to shoulder and especially not on the wing. He never consistently took people on the way Hatem did, or the way players like Hazard can. It's not his style and never has been, so to expect him to take to the PL and start playing that style is stupid to the nth degree.

 

If we, as a team, learn to pass the ball more and involve more off the ball movement, I can immediately see him stepping it up a level, due to the reduced physicality he would face.

 

Who would you compare him to at Montpellier?

 

He's not particularly similar to any of their current squad. Their number 7 Anthony Mounier is an out and out winger, and has took up Cabellas play making responsibility. After that, the rest of the team is average except Morgan Sanson, who we have been linked with previously.

 

Barrios, ex BVB player has done well, but he was only on loan from Russia, and played centre forward. So again, there is nowt to compare him with.

 

Any particular reason you want to compare him to his past squad? Because there is no chance we are signing players from them again, we have ruined MYM, and damaged Cabella so far.

Link to post
Share on other sites

At the end of the day, at Montpellier, he played as a central attacking midfielder, playing quick passes, and playing one twos, rarely going shoulder to shoulder and especially not on the wing. He never consistently took people on the way Hatem did, or the way players like Hazard can. It's not his style and never has been, so to expect him to take to the PL and start playing that style is stupid to the nth degree.

 

If we, as a team, learn to pass the ball more and involve more off the ball movement, I can immediately see him stepping it up a level, due to the reduced physicality he would face.

 

Who would you compare him to at Montpellier?

 

He's not particularly similar to any of their current squad. Their number 7 Anthony Mounier is an out and out winger, and has took up Cabellas play making responsibility. After that, the rest of the team is average except Morgan Sanson, who we have been linked with previously.

 

Barrios, ex BVB player has done well, but he was only on loan from Russia, and played centre forward. So again, there is nowt to compare him with.

 

Any particular reason you want to compare him to his past squad? Because there is no chance we are signing players from them again, we have ruined MYM, and damaged Cabella so far.

 

Sorry - I meant - from the player he was at in Montpellier, what player would liken him to? I did the lazy thing of thinking he was the HBA replacement. A wide man, skillful and someone that could get a lot of goals. He's not that player at all. Mata? Silva? Nasri?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry - I meant - from the player he was at in Montpellier, what player would liken him to? I did the lazy thing of thinking he was the HBA replacement. A wide man, skillful and someone that could get a lot of goals. He's not that player at all. Mata? Silva? Nasri?

 

I wanted him to be our HBA aswell, but I knew he wasn't as explosive, and playing him on the wing hasn't helped at all.

 

I would say he's a poor mans version of someone like Coutinho, clever passes, good movement, handful of goals and assists. In Ligue 1, where he had more time and space, he played some brilliant games, although with Montpellier being a midtable team, alot of it was counter attacking football. He was very often the player winning the ball high up the pitch and starting attacks. It's something I never understood about Pardews criticism of him, because he's actually pretty damn good at tackling for a creative midfielder.

 

Unfortunately he wont come close to replicating Coutihno type of performances for us, and he will never be Silva or Nasri good.

Link to post
Share on other sites

His decision making is the bigger problem rather than his physique IMO. He holds on to the ball far too long thinking about what to do and eventually gets muscled off it. Tbf if we had better movement he may see a pass quicker and get rid of it quicker

 

He delays on the ball because of the lack of movement - it was exactly the same with HBA.  No options so they hold onto it and then get abuse from the crowd for being greedy.

Why is this such a hard concept for people to grasp?

 

Two players who can play amazing through balls to runners (among other things) look like absolute toilet in a team where everyone but them stand still.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think he clearly has a lot of talent, would be a shame if he isn't able to realise that here. Personally I think his mental strength/resilience/determination is his biggest hinderance

 

I think it's coaching.

Link to post
Share on other sites

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/07/03/18/2A33E75A00000578-3148769-image-a-19_1435943189598.jpg

 

Caption competition

Woodman "See Steve, this is what happens when you don't float it to Willo"

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think he clearly has a lot of talent, would be a shame if he isn't able to realise that here. Personally I think his mental strength/resilience/determination is his biggest hinderance

 

I think it's coaching.

Same, direct one to one coaching since we signed him plus that fact everyone else around him has been crippled by the same coaching.

 

I'm hoping he stays, think he'll do well under the new team.

Link to post
Share on other sites

They were on a football field with a ball, of course they had a chance. I'd be looking to sell as many as could be replaced with about 7 exceptions.

:thup: You can't blame a manager for everything like. You can't just let him off the hook because he had bad managers

Link to post
Share on other sites

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/07/03/18/2A33E75A00000578-3148769-image-a-19_1435943189598.jpg

 

Caption competition

Woodman "See Steve, this is what happens when you don't float it to Willo"

 

Something happens when he hears the music...It's his freedom. It's his fire. It's his life. What a feeling.

Link to post
Share on other sites

They were on a football field with a ball, of course they had a chance. I'd be looking to sell as many as could be replaced with about 7 exceptions.

:thup: You can't blame a manager for everything like. You can't just let him off the hook because he had bad managers

Staggering, utterly staggering opinion considering the level of coaching, tactics and selections we've endured in the last 4-5 years.

Link to post
Share on other sites

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/07/03/18/2A33E75A00000578-3148769-image-a-19_1435943189598.jpg

 

Caption competition

Woodman "See Steve, this is what happens when you don't float it to Willo"

 

Something happens when he hears the music...It's his freedom. It's his fire. It's his life. What a feeling.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

They were on a football field with a ball, of course they had a chance. I'd be looking to sell as many as could be replaced with about 7 exceptions.

:thup: You can't blame a manager for everything like. You can't just let him off the hook because he had bad managers

Staggering, utterly staggering opinion considering the level of coaching, tactics and selections we've endured in the last 4-5 years.

 

 

Aye it's not just the managers, it's the coaching staff as a whole. Pardew probably wouldn't have been so bad if he had a decent backroom staff, but Pardew combined with a bunch of ball boys was utter aids. :anguish:

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

They were on a football field with a ball, of course they had a chance. I'd be looking to sell as many as could be replaced with about 7 exceptions.

:thup: You can't blame a manager for everything like. You can't just let him off the hook because he had bad managers

Staggering, utterly staggering opinion considering the level of coaching, tactics and selections we've endured in the last 4-5 years.

At various times Sissoko, Ben Arfa, Cabaye, Debuchy, Janmaat, Ba, Cisse all played well under that poor management. A poor manager isn't an excuse for playing shite

Link to post
Share on other sites

They were on a football field with a ball, of course they had a chance. I'd be looking to sell as many as could be replaced with about 7 exceptions.

:thup: You can't blame a manager for everything like. You can't just let him off the hook because he had bad managers

Staggering, utterly staggering opinion considering the level of coaching, tactics and selections we've endured in the last 4-5 years.

At various times Sissoko, Ben Arfa, Cabaye, Debuchy, Janmaat, Ba, Cisse all played well under that poor management. A poor manager isn't an excuse for playing shite

When the majority of players play poorly more often than they play well, and they're not shit players, then there's clearly a common denominator in the situation ffs. If it was 1-2 lazy flair monkeys then yeah I'd buy it, but it's not, it's been all of them for the vast majority of the time playing shite.

Link to post
Share on other sites

They were on a football field with a ball, of course they had a chance. I'd be looking to sell as many as could be replaced with about 7 exceptions.

:thup: You can't blame a manager for everything like. You can't just let him off the hook because he had bad managers

Staggering, utterly staggering opinion considering the level of coaching, tactics and selections we've endured in the last 4-5 years.

At various times Sissoko, Ben Arfa, Cabaye, Debuchy, Janmaat, Ba, Cisse all played well under that poor management. A poor manager isn't an excuse for playing s****

 

No one said it was, only that they are not playing to their potential consistently and a better coaching staff is more likely to bring it out. Even though all of them players had their moments under Pardew it was really was just one massive missed opportunity.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...