Jump to content

Jack Colback (now a free agent)


Recommended Posts

The hostility about Colback still baffles me. Either people made their minds up very early about his ability and are reluctant to adjust, or this resentment about his celebration for the Mackems still lingers on. As they say in Frozen, Let it go.

 

 

 

Or possibly people have seen nothing to suggest he's anything other than a bang average nothing player who we only signed because he was free.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest firetotheworks

The hostility about Colback still baffles me. Either people made their minds up very early about his ability and are reluctant to adjust, or this resentment about his celebration for the Mackems still lingers on. As they say in Frozen, Let it go.

I dunno what's worse, something baffling you that's been explained in depth or the fact that a fully grown adult has quoted Frozen.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Calling him a nothing player is absurd tbf. He is very good at breaking up opposition play and rarely loses possession, unlike some of the other daft bastards we have in the middle of the park. Needs to be more consistent in an attacking sense but at the time being he's better than any alternative we have available. That idiot Tiote should be out before anyone else.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The hostility about Colback still baffles me. Either people made their minds up very early about his ability and are reluctant to adjust, or this resentment about his celebration for the Mackems still lingers on. As they say in Frozen, Let it go.

I dunno what's worse, something baffling you that's been explained in depth or the fact that a fully grown adult has quoted Frozen.

 

I like how he felt that was a solid way to put his point across on a football forum. :lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites

He is bang average but one aspect of his game I hadn't really noticed until yesterday is that he seems to try and play the ball forwards as a rule, which is nice to watch. In a decent setup he'd be good back up for CM.

 

His use of the ball is good mostly, I've always said that, but he doesn't really do much running, that's why the opposition midfield seem to get a grip of the game even though we have an extra midfielder in there supposedly.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest firetotheworks

Calling him a nothing player is absurd tbf. He is very good at breaking up opposition play and rarely loses possession, unlike some of the other daft bastards we have in the middle of the park. Needs to be more consistent in an attacking sense but at the time being he's better than any alternative we have available. That idiot Tiote should be out before anyone else.

Like I've said before, I don't think he's good at that tbh. He's that sort of all action English midfielder that runs around trying to get the ball back like a puppy. I'm yet to see him do anything than other than that defensively. He rarely loses possession that's true, but he rarely does anything approaching risky in an attacking sense either, whenever I've watched us he's played the easiest pass for himself to make time after time.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Calling him a nothing player is absurd tbf. He is very good at breaking up opposition play and rarely loses possession, unlike some of the other daft bastards we have in the middle of the park. Needs to be more consistent in an attacking sense but at the time being he's better than any alternative we have available. That idiot Tiote should be out before anyone else.

Like I've said before, I don't think he's good at that tbh. He's that sort of all action English midfielder that runs around trying to get the ball back like a puppy. I'm yet to see him do anything than other than that defensively. He rarely loses possession that's true, but he rarely does anything approaching risky in an attacking sense either, whenever I've watched us he's played the easiest pass for himself to make time after time.

 

He's anything but an all action midfielder though. He trots around at a leisurely pace for the most part. He's best suited to games where we are camped in our own half and he can get behind the ball. In an open game he'd be overrun.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest firetotheworks

Calling him a nothing player is absurd tbf. He is very good at breaking up opposition play and rarely loses possession, unlike some of the other daft bastards we have in the middle of the park. Needs to be more consistent in an attacking sense but at the time being he's better than any alternative we have available. That idiot Tiote should be out before anyone else.

Like I've said before, I don't think he's good at that tbh. He's that sort of all action English midfielder that runs around trying to get the ball back like a puppy. I'm yet to see him do anything than other than that defensively. He rarely loses possession that's true, but he rarely does anything approaching risky in an attacking sense either, whenever I've watched us he's played the easiest pass for himself to make time after time.

 

He's anything but an all action midfielder though. He trots around at a leisurely pace for the most part. He's best suited to games where we are camped in our own half and he can get behind the ball. In an open game he'd be overrun.

I mean all action as in all he does when we don't have the ball in midfield is chase it. That's his only setting.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Calling him a nothing player is absurd tbf. He is very good at breaking up opposition play and rarely loses possession, unlike some of the other daft bastards we have in the middle of the park. Needs to be more consistent in an attacking sense but at the time being he's better than any alternative we have available. That idiot Tiote should be out before anyone else.

Like I've said before, I don't think he's good at that tbh. He's that sort of all action English midfielder that runs around trying to get the ball back like a puppy. I'm yet to see him do anything than other than that defensively. He rarely loses possession that's true, but he rarely does anything approaching risky in an attacking sense either, whenever I've watched us he's played the easiest pass for himself to make time after time.

 

He consistently leaves huge gaps in our midfield because his positional sense is awful,, he quite literally chases the ball. Good goal yesterday but that aside I thought he was terrible. He looks good to the average fan as he puts in a sliding challenge every now and again.

 

Also people still disputing he's Cabaye's replacement. :lol:

 

:lol: He's 5 appearances off Gosling's total within half a season, and Gosling was with us for 4 years.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Calling him a nothing player is absurd tbf. He is very good at breaking up opposition play and rarely loses possession, unlike some of the other daft bastards we have in the middle of the park. Needs to be more consistent in an attacking sense but at the time being he's better than any alternative we have available. That idiot Tiote should be out before anyone else.

Like I've said before, I don't think he's good at that tbh. He's that sort of all action English midfielder that runs around trying to get the ball back like a puppy. I'm yet to see him do anything than other than that defensively. He rarely loses possession that's true, but he rarely does anything approaching risky in an attacking sense either, whenever I've watched us he's played the easiest pass for himself to make time after time.

 

He consistently leaves huge gaps in our midfield because his positional sense is awful,, he quite literally chases the ball. Good goal yesterday but that aside I thought he was terrible. He looks good to the average fan as he puts in a sliding challenge every now and again.

 

Also people still disputing he's Cabaye's replacement. :lol:

 

He wasn't terrible yesterday, man. That's nonsense. And 'good to the average fan' :lol: What an outrageous egomaniac.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest firetotheworks

I agree with him. He hoys in a sliding tackle or blasts it out for a throw in and the average fans love it. It's audible, no one's hearing things.

Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing that's been said about him recently that I agree with until he proves otherwise is that he plays well when most of the team are playing well.  He's never one of 2 or 3 stand-out players when things aren't going well (like Sissoko/Perez/Janmaat often are) which considering his position on the pitch is a worrying sign he doesn't impose himself enough.  That might change but it's exactly what we've seen so far, him occasionally looking bright when things are going well and disappearing otherwise.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Was missing for the most part in the second half but then the team as a whole were unable to string two passes together. Was very good first half.

 

How can a central midfielder go missing for 45 mins? I mean Tiote had a bad game yesterday, he will often get caught on the ball, but no one could ever accuse him of going missing. I've seen Mehdi Abeid play in a few games now and the one thing he NEVER does is go missing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Midfield is an area where you can't just disappear or hide. It's all well and good putting in a good corner we score from and scoring a great goal but when the rest of your performance leaves huge holes that expose our defence and isolate the attackers and we concede 3 goals, at home, to one of the worst teams in the league, you can't defend that.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Should be paired with someone better than Tiote. I'd put him in with Abeid with Sissoko sitting further forward.

 

I think he should be paired with someone lazy so he has to do his own running instead of letting someone like Abeid or Sissoko do it for him.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...