Jump to content
Newcastle-Online

Rafael Benitez

Jesse Pinkman

by Jesse Pinkman
in Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

Benwell Lad

Benwell Lad

Posted
Posted

 

I'd heard from a decent source that a couple of Premier League clubs were interested in Dummet so he may well have acted on that.

Although many criticise him and prefer to highlight his limitations, within the game he's looked upon as a reliable defender and a good pro. No world beater but there's been a lot worse in the PL.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
themanupstairs

themanupstairs

Posted
Posted

 

I'd heard from a decent source that a couple of Premier League clubs were interested in Dummet so he may well have acted on that.

Although many criticise him and prefer to highlight his limitations, within the game he's looked upon as a reliable defender and a good pro. No world beater but there's been a lot worse in the PL.

 

The problem I have with Dummett is that he has very few attributes that are needed to play full-back effectively in the PL. Apart from his decent height and left foot, he almost has nothing else to play that position. Very early on when he made his first few appearances, he put in a few crosses and showed some pace down the flank. Hasn't been seen since.

 

As with everything else, if he's good enough for Rafa, he's good enough for me. I still believe though that his best position is as a left-sided CB.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Benwell Lad

Benwell Lad

Posted
Posted

 

I'd heard from a decent source that a couple of Premier League clubs were interested in Dummet so he may well have acted on that.

Although many criticise him and prefer to highlight his limitations, within the game he's looked upon as a reliable defender and a good pro. No world beater but there's been a lot worse in the PL.

 

The problem I have with Dummett is that he has very few attributes that are needed to play full-back effectively in the PL. Apart from his decent height and left foot, he almost has nothing else to play that position. Very early on when he made his first few appearances, he put in a few crosses and showed some pace down the flank. Hasn't been seen since.

 

As with everything else, if he's good enough for Rafa, he's good enough for me. I still believe though that his best position is as a left-sided CB.

 

Those limitations are very easy to highlight rather than the positives and we probably have to ask just who or what we are comparing him to ?

Very few out and out left backs, even in the PL, check every box.

As you mention, him also being comfortable as a CB enhances his usefulness to a squad and therefore his market value.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Kasper

Kasper

Posted
Posted

 

I'd heard from a decent source that a couple of Premier League clubs were interested in Dummet so he may well have acted on that.

Although many criticise him and prefer to highlight his limitations, within the game he's looked upon as a reliable defender and a good pro. No world beater but there's been a lot worse in the PL.

 

The problem I have with Dummett is that he has very few attributes that are needed to play full-back effectively in the PL. Apart from his decent height and left foot, he almost has nothing else to play that position. Very early on when he made his first few appearances, he put in a few crosses and showed some pace down the flank. Hasn't been seen since.

 

As with everything else, if he's good enough for Rafa, he's good enough for me. I still believe though that his best position is as a left-sided CB.

 

Those limitations are very easy to highlight rather than the positives and we probably have to ask just who or what we are comparing him to ?

Very few out and out left backs, even in the PL, check every box.

As you mention, him also being comfortable as a CB enhances his usefulness to a squad and therefore his market value.

 

It's also a balance thing. Dummett doesn't contribute offensively. We all know that. No assists in 44 matches is a terrible stat.

 

Chances created gives a pretty bleak view:

 

http://i.imgur.com/9gM5zqv.png

(from squawka)

 

Not sure how accurate that is but atleast gives you an idea.

 

How much of that is due to Dummett not having a very offensive player infront of him and how much is down to Dummett not supporting the winger enough offensively. What ever it is I'm sure Rafa is looking to fix that. You can bet every team will be aware of that and adjust accordingly.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Nate

Nate

Posted
Posted

DDysU_qXoAAuo-f?format=png

 

Looks like a salesman trying to laugh off the attention of rouge traders cameras

 

'I don't go cold calling, trying to sell people clothes pegs and dusters. I do sell dusters, but that's about five percent of what, you know, we do.'

Link to post
Share on other sites
cp40

cp40

Posted
Posted

DDysU_qXoAAuo-f?format=png

 

Looks like a salesman trying to laugh off the attention of rouge traders cameras

 

 

'Mr Benitez what do you have to say over accusations you have been selling vastly overpriced Sissokos to vulnerable buyers?'

Link to post
Share on other sites
TRon

TRon

Posted
Posted

 

I'd heard from a decent source that a couple of Premier League clubs were interested in Dummet so he may well have acted on that.

Although many criticise him and prefer to highlight his limitations, within the game he's looked upon as a reliable defender and a good pro. No world beater but there's been a lot worse in the PL.

 

The problem I have with Dummett is that he has very few attributes that are needed to play full-back effectively in the PL. Apart from his decent height and left foot, he almost has nothing else to play that position. Very early on when he made his first few appearances, he put in a few crosses and showed some pace down the flank. Hasn't been seen since.

 

As with everything else, if he's good enough for Rafa, he's good enough for me. I still believe though that his best position is as a left-sided CB.

 

Those limitations are very easy to highlight rather than the positives and we probably have to ask just who or what we are comparing him to ?

Very few out and out left backs, even in the PL, check every box.

As you mention, him also being comfortable as a CB enhances his usefulness to a squad and therefore his market value.

 

It's also a balance thing. Dummett doesn't contribute offensively. We all know that. No assists in 44 matches is a terrible stat.

 

Chances created gives a pretty bleak view:

 

http://i.imgur.com/9gM5zqv.png

(from squawka)

 

Not sure how accurate that is but atleast gives you an idea.

 

How much of that is due to Dummett not having a very offensive player infront of him and how much is down to Dummett not supporting the winger enough offensively. What ever it is I'm sure Rafa is looking to fix that. You can bet every team will be aware of that and adjust accordingly.

 

It's not even the assists that are that important, a good winger in front of him could make up for that. It's his general ineptness at bringing the ball out which hurts us more IMO. Good defender though, so I can see why Rafa would want to keep him until we can buy a genuine class LB.

Link to post
Share on other sites
NG32

NG32

Posted
Posted

DDysU_qXoAAuo-f?format=png

 

Looks like a salesman trying to laugh off the attention of rouge traders cameras

 

 

'Mr Benitez what do you have to say over accusations you have been selling vastly overpriced Sissokos to vulnerable buyers?'

 

Very good  :lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites
Sima

Sima

Posted
Posted

 

The problem I have with Dummett is that he has very few attributes that are needed to play full-back effectively in the PL. Apart from his decent height and left foot, he almost has nothing else to play that position. Very early on when he made his first few appearances, he put in a few crosses and showed some pace down the flank. Hasn't been seen since.

 

As with everything else, if he's good enough for Rafa, he's good enough for me. I still believe though that his best position is as a left-sided CB.

 

It was mint when Pardew had him taking all free kicks and corners.

Link to post
Share on other sites
sempuki

sempuki

Posted
Posted

Interesting from Caulkin:

 

GEORGE CAULKIN

july 5 2017, 12:00pm, the times

Difficult Newcastle owner providing Benítez with reassurances

 

Newcastle United’s training ground at the beginning of this week. As Rafa Benítez and his players reassembled for pre-season, catching up on gossip with the medical and fitness staff, swapping anecdotes about their summer holidays (not that the manager took one), there was the usual array of emotion; anticipation about the club’s return to the Premier League, excitement at the sense of possibility, pent up energy and nerves.

 

There was also something else, too, something which explains the strange mood which has hung around the club since their promotion in May, an easing of tension which has built and itched and niggled away. It felt like relief. After a testing, barren few weeks, which has seen transfers stall and logjam, Benítez was back on the grass, doing his stuff, finding percentages, seeking improvement where others would focus on flaws.

 

On Monday evening, when Florian Lejeune turned up to complete his £8.7 million signing from Eibar, there was another exhalation. Lejeune’s arrival was belated, but at least he was there, the 26-year-old centre half - who can also play in midfield - agreeing a five-year contract and becoming Newcastle’s first new addition (Christian Atsu had already joined from Chelsea, but was on-loan at St James’ Park last season).

 

Lejeune’s transfer had been described as “close” by a well-connected Newcastle source four weeks earlier. Benítez and his recruitment team had done all the groundwork, identifying the player, establishing the cost of his release clause, all the niceties that can be worked on. The same applied to a loan for Tammy Abraham, Chelsea’s England Under-21 striker and Willy Caballero, the goalkeeper, who was out of contract at Manchester City.

 

Benítez believed that each player was prepared to move to Tyneside and that tentative arrangements were in place. After a meeting with Mike Ashley in May, Newcastle’s owner had said that the Spaniard could have “every last penny that the club generates through promotion, player sales and other means in order to build for next season,” but that is not the same as writing the cheques or sending the decisive emails.

 

 

Having given his first list of names to Lee Charnley, the managing director, Benítez sat and waited. And then began to stew. Nothing happened. Chelsea moved for Caballero, Bournemouth and then Swansea City began courting Abraham. Benítez had been eager for a deal to be sorted before the Under-21 European Championship, but that deadline came and went. And then Abraham went to Swansea. From Benítez’s perspective, it was avoidable.

 

Edginess in transfer windows is not a new phenomenon, but what applies to most clubs has been magnified at Ashley’s Newcastle. Historically, part of that can be explained by the shape of their hierarchy - the limited power of the manager or head coach, the influence wielded by Graham Carr, the chief scout - and also by their transfer policy, the requirement to source younger players, often foreign, with a view to finding worth.

 

Benítez’s arrival blurred that. He has the final say on transfers. Carr, who should have been given a graceful exit a year ago, has now gone. And if there is still a desire that Newcastle should find value, then he has no problem with that. But it remains a strange club, with a strange way of doing things, reflecting Ashley’s unpredictability. And there is a feeling that Charnley has been caught in the middle, appeasing above and beneath him as much as making decisions.

 

When Ashley, previously an absentee landlord, suddenly turned up for matches in January, accompanied by the marginalised Carr, Benítez was bewildered, particularly when the sportswear retailer did not speak to him. Benítez asked for new players to propel Newcastle towards promotion; none came. When Newcastle went up, days went by before Ashley called to offer his congratulations. It made for unease.

 

In the background, there have been other complications, other sources of confusion, from the HMRC raid in late April which saw Charnley arrested and then released without charge, the involvement of Julian Barnes, a lawyer and long-time Ashley “fixer”, in financial and strategic matters at St James’, to the story - which disappeared into thin air - that there was Chinese interest in a takeover of Newcastle.

 

If this presents a wholly negative view of Newcastle, then it is unfair. Benítez remains hugely popular with supporters, a manager of genuine calibre who thinks of his club in terms of stature and potential, rather than crushed by limitation, or drained of vigour, as it had been under Steve McClaren. To have a man defined by winning things at the head of a club allergic to silverware still feels transformative.

 

It also feels delicate. Benítez has worked at Liverpool, Chelsea, Read Madrid, Inter Milan; few understand the machinations of football better than him. He knows about politics. Reports in Sunday newspapers a couple of weekends ago that the 57-year-old had become disillusioned were well-sourced and reflective, but were also a warning to Newcastle. The question is how much Ashley will have noticed and how he would respond.

 

Benítez is realistic. His concern is that the Newcastle team which came up is not equipped to compete in the Premier League and he does not want to be embarrassed at Anfield, Stamford Bridge or anywhere else. Even consolidation will take effort and although club directors will always tell you that no transfer is straightforward - and Newcastle’s squad requires trimming - opportunities have been missed.

 

As much as Newcastle need players - Benítez has no substantive interest in Manchester City’s Joe Hart, nor in Sam Clucas or Kamil Grosicki of Hull City, who have all been mentioned as potential targets - it also about relations and whether they can remain viable. Benítez is not an easy manager, but then neither was Kevin Keegan. Nor are José Mourinho and Pep Guardiola. They demand. They push.

 

Good owners know when to listen, when to push back. The problem at Newcastle is that second-guessing Ashley is fraught with peril. He is not an easy owner. He can disappear for months and then take an interest, put pressure on Charnley for sanctioning a transfer that has not worked out. Disquiet then ripples outwards. It is why this week has brought some reassurance, players training again, the manager coaching. But at Newcastle, at this Newcastle, the itch is always there.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Sir Toon

Sir Toon

Posted
Posted

Learned nothing new in that article.  It's obvious most of the names thrown around are by club stooges who are trying to make it look like we're actively looking for players.  Stuff will be happening but at a very slow pace with us relying on tip offs or agent deals.  The same with the takeover talk, just done to cloud the mind. 

 

If the Lejeune deal has been done for over 4 weeks with just a contract needing to be signed then you can guarantee that Rafa's piss is boiling with nowt done since.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Tiresias

Tiresias

Posted
Posted

I always thought Dummet looked more solid as a Centre Back than at left back. Not happy with offering him a new contract to be honest. I don't hate him too much, he just seems a workhorse without any outstanding qualities, he certainly isn't good enough on the ball to be helping out in attack.

Link to post
Share on other sites
TRon

TRon

Posted
Posted

What a read that article is man. Ashley is an absolute nightmare.

 

It just basically confirms our fears assuming Caulkin isn't just making it up. Rafa has gone without a holiday in order to set up some tasty deals only for Ashley's lackeys to fail to deliver on most of them.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Kanj

Kanj

Posted
Posted

I'm a little bummed we didn't get Abraham as I would have loved to see him play here and develop, but it was a loan deal and likely a 1 season rent. Not arsed at all about Willy being our potential #1 GK either.

 

Happy about Clucas and Grosicki as I can't really say they excited me at all (granted I don't think I've really much to offer on opinion so a semi-crap statement on my part). Hoping for some exciting names/players ala the duo from Sporting a month or so ago.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Eddy Chibas

Eddy Chibas

Posted
Posted
He can disappear for months and then take an interest, put pressure on Charnley for sanctioning a transfer that has not worked out, will even undermine a manager's groundwork on the recruitment front by vetoing a transfer which is central to a manager's building plans as seen with Keegan's failed bid to secure Luka Modric's signature
Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...