Jump to content
Newcastle-Online

Fabian Schär

54

by 54
in Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

Smal

Smal

Posted
Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, LFEE said:

Again. That’s not what I’m arguing. 

 

What do you mean then, sorry?

 

"Ball at their feet there is no contest with Colo coming out on top."

 

 

Edited by Smal

Link to post
Share on other sites
LFEE

LFEE

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, Pata said:

Colo’s close control and technique was the best I’ve ever seen from a CB. Schär is obviously good on the ball too but his long passing can be a bit hit and miss, glorious ball played is often followed by one that’s nowhere near the target. 
 

Hope Schär has many years left on the top level, he’s been magnificent since the takeover.

Totally wasted under Bruce. Shame we couldn’t get those two years back for him.

Link to post
Share on other sites
LFEE

LFEE

Posted
Posted
Just now, Smal said:

 

What do you mean then, sorry?

 

"Ball at their feet there is no contest with Colo coming out on top."

 

 

 

Comfort on the ball. Dribbling passed forwards. Bring ball down in tight spaces. Playing out in tight spaces. Reading of the game and anticipation with cute nudges and interceptions and flicks of the ball whilst not having recovery pace. What I would describe as the small side of the game where your footballing ability needs to be at its highest. It was like he was playing futsal at times. Just natural footballing ability.

 

Long passing and aerially and physically Schär is better and has a greater goal threat but I said that in the op along with saying they both lack a yard of pace. Actually think Colo hid it better with his reading of the game maybe slightly better also. 
 

Love Schär but between them there’s only one I’m backing stuck in the corner flag surrounded by attackers.

Link to post
Share on other sites
The College Dropout

The College Dropout

Posted
Posted

I get what you're saying. Colo was a more "natural footballer". A better baller.

 

As a CB i'd take Schar though. But the different eras and managers is a massive difference. If we sold Schar under Bruce we'd say he couldn't play in a back 4, slow, relatively poor in the air etc.

 

A fully fit squad we're massive like. Schar is good in the air but he's not dominant. He'd struggle badly with Raylor LB, Mbiwa next to him with Anita & Colback in midfield.

 

Now we've got Joelinton, Burn who often get their heads on defensive set pieces. And less strikers that are aerially dominant.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Kanji

Kanji

Posted
Posted

Schar is our best ball playing CB we've ever had and I would counter argue that his long and short passing ability + his shooting/penalties add to that. Colo was a fantastic dribbler but don't recall him creating anything from his passing or carrying, there wasn't reverse passes like Botman or Schar, there wasn't aggressive diagonals etc. Colo the footballer, reader of game, etc clearly more easy on the eye but I don't really think he'd be able to handle some of today's footballers. 

 

JUST my opinion. :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites
TRon

TRon

Posted
Posted
On 25/09/2023 at 19:45, TheBrownBottle said:

Schar better than Woodgate?

 

Nowt like getting carried away after a big win :) 

 

Woodgate is still the best all round centre back I've ever seen playing for us. When he was fit and up and running, he had everything.

 

I like Coloccini as well, but he wasn't at that level. Still easily one of our best players during the Ashley era, although I guess that's not saying much. He might have come out second best to one or two strikers, but Schar has done the same. It's Botman who is the rock in our defence, when he's not there, Schar looks far less sure of himself.

Link to post
Share on other sites
madras

madras

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, TRon said:

 

Woodgate is still the best all round centre back I've ever seen playing for us. When he was fit and up and running, he had everything.

 

I like Coloccini as well, but he wasn't at that level. Still easily one of our best players during the Ashley era, although I guess that's not saying much. He might have come out second best to one or two strikers, but Schar has done the same. It's Botman who is the rock in our defence, when he's not there, Schar looks far less sure of himself.

Got to say Botman is up there with Woodgate.

Link to post
Share on other sites
mattypnufc

mattypnufc

Posted
Posted
5 minutes ago, TRon said:

 

Woodgate is still the best all round centre back I've ever seen playing for us. When he was fit and up and running, he had everything.

 

I like Coloccini as well, but he wasn't at that level. Still easily one of our best players during the Ashley era, although I guess that's not saying much. He might have come out second best to one or two strikers, but Schar has done the same. It's Botman who is the rock in our defence, when he's not there, Schar looks far less sure of himself.

All 28 games of it. It’s a real shame he didn’t play more for us as he was absolute mustard, but that amount of games is shocking. Genuinely think it paints a better picture of him (Woodgate) due to the amount of games he didn’t play…whilst Botman has racked up 50 already.
 

Schar is great but Botman is head and shoulders (literally and physically) above Schar. And they quite clearly work very very well together. 
 

We need an understudy to Schar in this Jan/Summer window that’s for sure. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
TRon

TRon

Posted
Posted
Just now, mattypnufc said:

All 28 games of it. It’s a real shame he didn’t play more for us as he was absolute mustard, but that amount of games is shocking. Genuinely think it paints a better picture of him (Woodgate) due to the amount of games he didn’t play…whilst Botman has racked up 50 already.
 

Schar is great but Botman is head and shoulders (literally and physically) above Schar. And they quite clearly work very very well together. 
 

We need an understudy to Schar in this Jan/Summer window that’s for sure. 

 

Not going to disagree with any of that, Woodgate was useless for us for vast periods of his time here, but when he was there he took us to the champions league, and we got some pretty great results against some mighty European teams on the back of his class. He was probably the only defender who could make Titus Bramble look like a champion.

Link to post
Share on other sites
toon25

toon25

Posted
Posted

Appreciate that the game has changed, but for some reason Woodgate's performance in that game v. Marseilles in 2004 (which ended 0-0 but he kept Drogba in his pocket) will always be one of the best CB showings I've ever seen.

Link to post
Share on other sites
MrRaspberryJam

MrRaspberryJam

Posted
Posted
19 minutes ago, toon25 said:

Appreciate that the game has changed, but for some reason Woodgate's performance in that game v. Marseilles in 2004 (which ended 0-0 but he kept Drogba in his pocket) will always be one of the best CB showings I've ever seen.


He was shit. Drogba ran him ragged you haven’t a clue what you’re going on about

Link to post
Share on other sites
Ronaldo

Ronaldo

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, LFEE said:

Nice little clip show some of Colo’s game. Think surround by this defence and midfield he’d have no problems at all.

 

 


Does it omit the dozen or so times we lost 4-0+ when he threw the towel in? I liked Colo a lot for a while but post 2013 he was garbage. An easy mark CB.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Pancrate1892

Pancrate1892

Posted
Posted
On 26/09/2023 at 22:58, TRon said:

 

Not going to disagree with any of that, Woodgate was useless for us for vast periods of his time here, but when he was there he took us to the champions league, and we got some pretty great results against some mighty European teams on the back of his class. He was probably the only defender who could make Titus Bramble look like a champion.

Apart from when we lost 2-6 man utd. That was a bad day at the office for both of them. Bramble obviously more common 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...