Marc Guehi

[Andy84]

Debut on Sunday?

[Upthemags]

Someone explain to me the downside of going after Guehi again in January or the summer when his valuation deflates 15m

[The Prophet]

Just now, Upthemags said:

Someone explain to me the downside of going after Guehi again in January or the summer when his valuation deflates 15m

 

There will be more interest in him. We currently have a free run at him.

[AyeDubbleYoo]

1 minute ago, Upthemags said:

Someone explain to me the downside of going after Guehi again in January or the summer when his valuation deflates 15m

 

He can't play for us until January?

[BottledDog]

3 minutes ago, 80 said:

I don't totally disagree, but we probably need that character up front rather than in defence.

 

We have it! Nobody can tell me Isak isn't a fucking nutcase of a man. 

 

2 minutes ago, KDT said:

 

Our centre midfielder just clotheslined someone last game & the week before that we had a player sent of for a headbutt (soft).

 

Yeah, that head butt didn't impress me either. Schar is too much of a good egg.

[nufcnick]

1 minute ago, Upthemags said:

Someone explain to me the downside of going after Guehi again in January or the summer when his valuation deflates 15m

Because about 4 other/better clubs would be in for him at that price 

[madras]

19 minutes ago, BottledDog said:

 

Arguably though Andy, the team lacks edge, not good eggs.

 

Howe will never see it, but maybe we need a gallic shrug of a man, a disruptor, a bad boy.

Haven't we just been described as animals ?

[Upthemags]

Just now, The Prophet said:

 

There will be more interest in him. We currently have a free run at him.

That's a fair point. From my perspective, I guess I don't really understand our logic then on holding out over 5m. We're already in dreamland deal value territory at 65m for the lad, and by all indications, he is the be all end all top target for Eddie, so why make a big fuss over something slightly over that valuation?

 

Confusing.

[Upthemags]

2 minutes ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

 

He can't play for us until January?

Now this is some incisive insight

[BottledDog]

1 minute ago, madras said:

Haven't we just been described as animals ?

 

 

[AyeDubbleYoo]

Just now, Upthemags said:

Now this is some incisive insight

 

Ask a silly question... 

[Zero]

3 minutes ago, The Prophet said:

 

There will be more interest in him. We currently have a free run at him.

 

I like the word “free”

[Sibierski]

5 minutes ago, Andy84 said:

Debut on Sunday?

 

Bullet head, assist, as we win 4-1. 

 

Then off to England squad where he does his hammy and we don't see him again till late November.

[FloydianMag]

Just now, Zero said:

 

I like the word “free”

It’s about the only fucking thing that’s free in the whole saga!

[Deuce]

32 minutes ago, Andy said:

 

We seem to scout based on personality as much as footballing ability though. It may be that there are other targets out there with similar potential ability to Guehi, like Lacroix for example, but the club's interest is driven by more than that. 

 

Guehi is a leader and clearly a good egg too based on the way he has handled this transfer, also very popular amongst other players by all accounts. 

Too many people treat transfers as some kind of plug-and-play exercise. FIFA/FM on the brain.
 

“Why pay so much for Guehi when we could have *insert player* for only half as much?”

 

Because we want Guehi and don’t want that other player? Because we have concerns about that other player fitting in well to the squad, or adapting to Premier League football?
 

Transfer histories are littered with promising young players who disappear like a fart in the wind after a season or two.

[Upthemags]

15 minutes ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

 

Ask a silly question... 

In a hypothetical world where we can have Guehi for 50m in January, is his joining us now worth ~20m to you?

 

Edit: Happy to spell out the question more clearly for you.

 

 

Edited Wednesday at 14:10 by Upthemags

[Coffee_Johnny]

2 hours ago, gdm said:

 

That tash knocks £50m off his value for a start. I hope they check his birth certificate as I’m sure he featured as washing machine repair man in an 80’s porno. 

[gbandit]

If we do sign a different defender and Guehi stays at Palace then I can imagine it being a massive regret for him for the rest of his playing days 

[Jordan whyayew]

My understanding is he is now likely to stay at Palace and sign a new contract with a release clause. He expected other clubs to be in for him.

 

He is happy at Palace but wants Champions League level football. Newcastle seen as a sideways move with more downside than upside. A release clause in a new contract gets him financial security and the freedom to move if the right club comes in for him. (Eze and Olise in same position at Palace)

 

Mitchell messed up with his nonsensical low balls. 70 million 3 weeks ago and he would be wearing black and white now

[gbandit]

Just now, Jordan whyayew said:

My understanding is he is now likely to stay at Palace and sign a new contract with a release clause. He expected other clubs to be in for him.

 

He is happy at Palace but wants Champions League level football. Newcastle seen as a sideways move with more downside than upside. A release clause in a new contract gets him financial security and the freedom to move if the right club comes in for him. (Eze and Olise in same position at Palace)

 

Mitchell messed up with his nonsensical low balls. 70 million 3 weeks ago and he would be wearing black and white now

Thanks Marra

[Kid Icarus]

Just now, Jordan whyayew said:

My understanding is he is now likely to stay at Palace and sign a new contract with a release clause. He expected other clubs to be in for him.

 

He is happy at Palace but wants Champions League level football. Newcastle seen as a sideways move with more downside than upside. A release clause in a new contract gets him financial security and the freedom to move if the right club comes in for him. (Eze and Olise in same position at Palace)

 

Mitchell messed up with his nonsensical low balls. 70 million 3 weeks ago and he would be wearing black and white now

 

Your understanding being backed with...?

[nufcnick]

1 minute ago, Jordan whyayew said:

My understanding is he is now likely to stay at Palace and sign a new contract with a release clause. He expected other clubs to be in for him.

 

He is happy at Palace but wants Champions League level football. Newcastle seen as a sideways move with more downside than upside. A release clause in a new contract gets him financial security and the freedom to move if the right club comes in for him. (Eze and Olise in same position at Palace)

 

Mitchell messed up with his nonsensical low balls. 70 million 3 weeks ago and he would be wearing black and white now

Another ITK know fuck all nugget 

[CallumG6]

1 minute ago, Jordan whyayew said:

My understanding is he is now likely to stay at Palace and sign a new contract with a release clause. He expected other clubs to be in for him.

 

He is happy at Palace but wants Champions League level football. Newcastle seen as a sideways move with more downside than upside. A release clause in a new contract gets him financial security and the freedom to move if the right club comes in for him. (Eze and Olise in same position at Palace)

 

Mitchell messed up with his nonsensical low balls. 70 million 3 weeks ago and he would be wearing black and white now

[Pixelphish]

Just now, Kid Icarus said:

 

Your understanding being backed with...?

Being from Wearside.

[r0cafella]

2 minutes ago, gbandit said:

If we do sign a different defender and Guehi stays at Palace then I can imagine it being a massive regret for him for the rest of his playing days 

Why would it be? He either signs a new deal on more money with a release clause or he goes next summer to a club like Liverpool who are currently a step ahead of us.