toontownman

Looks like this one is actually happening. I dont really see what either club gains from it. Of course we do get the better end of the deal though. Mido would come here, if fit and motivated would be a solid signing, that sounds just like the last guy we bought from the smogs though. Mido is probably the best player we can hope for in our current state. Its a strange one, why Boro would want to lose one of their better players for Alan Smith who really doesnt give them anything they dont have is beyond me. Can see Smith refusing them though, not sure if that leaves us looking elsewhere for a striker or a straight cash deal for Mido (who will come imo). He surely cant be so expensive just to buy straight out.

I actually think we will cash in on him. I will be livid if we do, we wont sign anyone as good let alone better this month. expect us to sell him for 3m then fail to get anyone else in to reinforce the midfield.

Wishful thinking. would still like to see him here. different to any striker on our books. not a chance of it happening though.

I was just about to post that. I'm officially excited. No-one burst my bubble please!!! Why are you excited? We're not linked with him in the article - which has no quotes and is by goal.com. So to burst your bubble by the way Off to Mackems. http://www.setanta.com//uk/Articles/Football/2009/2/5/Exclusive-MBami-agent-on-Sland/gnid-34036/ sorry should be in other clubs thread, it was mentioned in here though.

I'd be suprised if he isnt offered the job if we dont go down. If we do go down I wouldnt be suprised if they kept him on either, its getting closer to his level.

Feck me, the worst part is its probably true!

For the most part Rangers fans could care less about him right now, cant run with the ball, never shoots and more than not watches the game pass him by, he can apparently retain the ball ok. Good ball watcher though. I dont think we will sign anyone better this window, infact he is probably light years better than what we end up with.

butt's been offered a new contract I know, wasn't it part of his previous contract and performance based? regardless, he more than anyone in our squad is a player I'd expect to think about leaving, should we sell Given/Owen. Just because we have offered him an extension and we dont think he deserves it, doesnt mean he wants the extension.

I was screaming to have him put on today. Its a dissapointing affair to say the least. I can understand if maybe he isnt ready for the premier league or even suited to it, but why the hell arent we trying him out in the reserves? I know JFK see's him in training every day, but he has played treble the amount of league games Carrol has, scored many times in one of the best leagues in the world and played with some great players. I know we dont know the full facts (which is always the most frustrating albeit loop hole excuse) but for the love of God he must have something about him worth giving him a chance over Andy fucking Carrol

I thought he did much better today, yes he should have scored at least one, but he was involved more than he has been the last 5/6 games. I wouldnt say he is past it (although he certainly isn't the same as he was a few years ago) as much as he isn't utilised in the best way. I would love to see him stay, but I wouldn't be opposed to cashing in on him asap as the former is not going to happen. In many ways his decision was a low blow, given our support of him, we deserved a decision one way or the other by now to get money back on him. That said, I'm sure he also thinks its a loyal thing to stick it out to the end of the season, but money or clubwise I doubt many people would do different though in his position. Like losing Given, the impact on the pitch would be alot less influenced than off it and around the club. There is a huge sway of belief that either of these two leaving would see a mass mutiny and exodous. Tbh I can't see anyone walking that we couldnt aptdly replace. Butt - leave N'Zogbia - possible loss, but one a long time coming, not convinced he would leave unless he is guarenteed first team slots every week. Viduka - gone in the summer anyway, like butt Oba - whilst, it would be a bad sign of our intent going forward, he would get more games guarenteed, which is his only gripe, I dont think he would leave immediately. Duff- I doubt he would leave unless he was pushed, the few that would be interested wouldnt match his wages anyway If anything its a sign we are willing to have people that want to bring this club back where we want it to be, although the press will call it a mass walk out etc.. Long story short, I dont think there is anyone likely to leave that we couldnt (although kinnear wont find or attract them) replace.

Why don't you cut and wash your hair?

Are you in or out? I'll shake it all about if you don't mind. If the said people had enough money/experience/commitment/vision/nouse to make a success of it, its a bonus if they are Geordie owners. Sounds more like too many cooks spoiling the broth for me though.

the best person to run the club is obviously the person that wants the best for the club which was the thinking behind Roeders stunning spell in charge.

That's just what happens when you employ Kinnear as your manager.....it's just asking for it!!! As overly elaberate a way of getting back at those who criticised his system as is possible.

Lets build a barracade around the city and never let anyone from outside newcastle in, maybe burn any newcastle fan that wasn't born within 50 miles of the city, ok 40. Rich People from newcastle = perfect owner of the club. I know I'm dramatising your point to the full, but what makes you think said people would be perfect for the job, if anything wouldn't their natural bias blind them and be more of a liability? thomas said it best.

Another solid performance, needs to work on his distribution, every now and again looks a little clumsy, but is doing really well.

Getting better with each handfull of games imo. HTT isn't wrong though, needs replacing in the first team, he will get his chance. We will knacker him out soon enough otherwise, or the usual build him up and knock him down syndrome will take effect.

Never, never, never, never, never want to see him starting again. He is done. Might be a great pro and good for the dressing room but lets get 300k for him and sell him now.

This is what happens when you take away the transfer system we had and give Kinnear the wheel. Fuck me, what a terrible fucking signing. Replacement for Butt? Kinnear will probably drop Guthrie.

Have always thought that was one of Shays weakest points, although there are few keepers in the league that really do have the whole package, Harper is no better for it. This transfer might well have been a shock to us and JFK, but maybe not to the hierachy, lets not forget we have been linked to about 10 keepers over the past year. No coincidence.

Dont think Enrique is going anywhere, regardless of the fact he wont pass a medical right now he is the only LB on our books, he will stay to the end of the season at least. Carrol, Edgar, cacapa, Krul then maybe Xisco are more likely to be out the door. Dont think Geremi is expendable right now given his experience and versatility.

Tears before bed time again. I already want the transfer window to be shut. Infact bring on the end of the season. At least the away games will be cheaper next year.

You cant really argue with this. Yet again. He is as good as gone and City would be were I would see him ending up, if its city bidding 10m is cheap at the price.

Swap deal for Babel would be nice. More likely to get Benayoun, which I wouldnt be unhappy about either.

It's weird at times how players who are top class just fade away. He's been on his way down for a while I think, quality at Valencia but didn't really do it at Zaragoza so he was always a risk. Perhaps the disppointment of the move to NUFC falling down crushed him mentally Apparently it had the same effect on every player in a newcastle shirt too.