Jump to content
Newcastle-Online

Manchester United 1 - 1 Newcastle - 17/08/08 - post match reaction from page 26

Dave

by Dave
in Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

Mike

Mike

Posted
Posted

Coloccini and Taylor got better and better the longer the match went on. If it wasn't for N'Zogbia and Butt they wouldn't have had a sniff.

 

Beye looks a bit lacking in match sharpness btw.

 

Thought he looked as good as he did last year except for the first time he wasn't the only competent player on the pitch.

Link to post
Share on other sites
AyeDubbleYoo

AyeDubbleYoo

Posted
Posted

Very pleased today obviously, was just so beautiful to go to Old Trafford and fight, take the game to them and score. Honestly, if we'd lost by the odd goal I would still have been content, it's just such a difference in attitude/approach.

 

Allardyce was an expert in telling players what not to do and how cautious they need to be, Keegan is a master of getting them to imagine what they can achieve.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Dave

Dave

Posted
Posted

http://cache2.asset-cache.net/xc/82393011.jpg?v=1&c=NewsMaker&k=2&d=17A4AD9FDB9CF19368FFB0B613D6DEB0971236F43242818CE30A760B0D811297

 

Did Mike lose a bet?

 

Coloccini in the crowd!

Link to post
Share on other sites
oldtype

oldtype

Posted
Posted

Brilliant. What a way to start my week.

 

Given - Some super saves in the opening minutes to keep us in it, did his job tidily for the rest. Hopefully a sign that he's back to his peak. - 8

 

Beye - Exploited a few times early in the match and a bit static throughout. Solid work, but I know he's capable of better - 6

 

N'Zogbia - Obviously cannot defend, but I can see where KK is coming from here since Guttierez seems capable of doing more than enough defending for everyone on the left side. Certainly helps on the counter-attack when you have the pace of Zoggy on the left as opposed to the relatively immobile Enrique, but I'd much rather have an actual defender that doesn't cause me heart problems whenever an opposition player goes near him with the ball. - 5

 

Coloccini - Started out very shaky but was a much better player once he began to establish an understanding with the rest of the defensive line. Love his strength and how comfortable he is on the ball, although perhaps it's that very comfort that's making him dwell on the ball a bit more than a CB should. - 6

 

 

Taylor - Think we saw the very best of Steven Taylor today. Got into all the right positions and made vital tackles and cuts to stop ManU's attacking momentum. Also provided a great attacking threat for set pieces. As has been mentioned, Conceding the goal today was a direct result of Taylor being out for treatment. - 8

 

Jonas - Oh my God, where do I start. Amazing work rate that puts him all over the pitch, quick feet and a quick head that allows him to spearhead counterattacks, and that brilliant attitude of his: you can clearly see that he's enjoying his work. Reminds me a bit of Man U's Park but with much better strength and being offered a lot more freedom . I'm going to blatantly knee-jerk here and say he's going to be our player of the season and this year's equivalent to Martin Petrov. If any single performance can justify that sort of praise, it was this. Only wish he had scored. - 9

 

Milner - Clearly appeared to be the least talented of our "front 4" today and the weak link in our attack. Think he'll do a lot better when he's not up against one of the world's best defensive units like this week, but howay... How poor does Jonas make Milner look in comparison - 5

 

Guthrie - Decent debut. Took a bit of time to settle down and establish himself and made some decent creative efforts. Think he'll be a very good player for us given time, but obviously not the solution to our playmaker problem. - 6

 

Butt - Did what Nicky Butt does best, right down to the very, very unwise last minute foul. He's still capable of doing his job, but I would love to see us replace him with someone with better passing range. - 5

 

Duff - This is the fastest and fittest I've ever seen Duff in a Toon shirt, and while he frankly didn't contribute anything solid, gave me a lot of hope that he can still do a job for us. Loved how he, Jonas, and Martins used their pace and work rate to switch around and try to confuse the Man U defense. Nothing came of it today but would love to see this partnership continue to develop. - 6

 

Martins - A match that showed what Obafemi Martins is all about. Looked a bit unfit, and was bossed around by two superb central defenders for most of the game, but still able to pull a brilliant header out of nowhere and caused Man U a lot of problems.  - 7

 

 

Overall I have to say I'm very impressed with our new signings, but even more so with how much better the team seems to work with each other. Obviously having a full pre-season has done wonders for KK's ability to build a cohesive unit: both tactically and mentally.

 

Also have to mention that I'm intrigued how KK basically tried to play Man U's formation from last year, using three free-roaming attacking players behind a lone striker. While the end result obviously wasn't as destructive due to the sheer gap in quality, the work rate, pace, and unpredictability of Martins, Jonas, and Duff did seem to alllow us to pull of a similar strategy with good effect. Would be very interested in seeing how the formation would work with Owen coming in for Milner and playing as a withdrawn striker behind Martins, with Jonas and Duff on the flanks. At the very least, it would make for some brilliant football to watch.

 

It's fairly obvious, but with a new LB, a new DM, and a striker in for backup, we could be in for a cracking season.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...