Papiss Cissé

[Fenham Mag]

He doesn't deserve his place in the team at the moment, Gouf deserves to start.

[Foluwashola]

Our threat was always going to be from wide areas today. He kept their 2 CBs occupied which freed up space for HBA/Remy/Gouf.

 

He didn't tear up any trees but he was alright.

 

This. Think the trifecta of Remy, Ben Arfa and Cisse will be fantastic so happy to stick with it.

 

Don't see Gouffran as the focal point of a front 3. Think impact sub is his role, as much as he probably deserves a start.

[Cajun]

Our threat was always going to be from wide areas today. He kept their 2 CBs occupied which freed up space for HBA/Remy/Gouf.

 

He didn't tear up any trees but he was alright.

 

This. Think the trifecta of Remy, Ben Arfa and Cisse will be fantastic so happy to stick with it.

 

Don't see Gouffran as the focal point of a front 3. Think impact sub is his role, as much as he probably deserves a start.

 

What does Cisse provide as that focal point? IMO Gouffran has more to his game and there is nothing that currently sticks out to favour Cisse.

[Foluwashola]

Our threat was always going to be from wide areas today. He kept their 2 CBs occupied which freed up space for HBA/Remy/Gouf.

 

He didn't tear up any trees but he was alright.

 

This. Think the trifecta of Remy, Ben Arfa and Cisse will be fantastic so happy to stick with it.

 

Don't see Gouffran as the focal point of a front 3. Think impact sub is his role, as much as he probably deserves a start.

 

What does Cisse provide as that focal point? IMO Gouffran has more to his game and there is nothing that currently sticks out to favour Cisse.

 

As wor Lotus said, he keeps the defence occupied and is more likely to put any chances away than Gouffran, despite current form.

 

Just think we need to play an out-and-out striker tbh. We ain't no España.

[Cajun]

Gouffran played two seasons as an out and out strike scoring 1 in 2 before joining us. Plus he has better movement than Cisse imo.

 

Cisse had a worse scoring record than Gouffran has when playing in the same position too.

 

Each to their own, I just think Gouffran has been better than Cisse over the last 10 games or so and deserves a chance to show what he can do centrally while Cisse isn't performing.

[pedro111]

Sooner or later I think he's gonna start banging them in again. Gotta stick with him.

[Shak]

He'll always be a frustrating player I think, but he'll start scoring goals again soon I'm sure.

 

Ideally would like our next signing to be a pacey wide man who can play either side. Would give us the option of playing Remy centrally occasionally too, which might ultimately be his best spot.

 

Imagine we'd signed Thauvin and had the option of him and Ben Arfa either side of Remy.

 

[Guest]

If only we'd signed Gomis. Really think that style of striker in that set up is what we miss.

[Numbers]

He will come good, he's just having a dodgy spell.

[Dave]

I'd love it if opposition defenders were as quick to write him off as some Newcastle fans.

 

He had a shit season last time out but he wasn't helped by being basically our only hope after Ba went (a partnership that Pardew never got working anyway). He's scored goals on a regular basis all his career, with better movement and a greater goal threat from others around him I have little doubt that he'll come good again.

[Dave]

The Wonga bollocks won't have helped either.

[TRon]

Our threat was always going to be from wide areas today. He kept their 2 CBs occupied which freed up space for HBA/Remy/Gouf.

 

He didn't tear up any trees but he was alright.

 

This. Think the trifecta of Remy, Ben Arfa and Cisse will be fantastic so happy to stick with it.

 

Don't see Gouffran as the focal point of a front 3. Think impact sub is his role, as much as he probably deserves a start.

 

What does Cisse provide as that focal point? IMO Gouffran has more to his game and there is nothing that currently sticks out to favour Cisse.

 

Goal threat. You could play Gouffran instead but then Remy would be the main striker, and it might be worth a try at some point. I still see Remy and Cisse as the main strikers and Gouffran as a support striker. Happy to have all three of them here at the moment, we could have done with Gomis as well, but I think we can get goals out of those three.

[Unbelievable]

I'd love it if opposition defenders were as quick to write him off as some Newcastle fans.

 

He had a s*** season last time out but he wasn't helped by being basically our only hope after Ba went (a partnership that Pardew never got working anyway). He's scored goals on a regular basis all his career, with better movement and a greater goal threat from others around him I have little doubt that he'll come good again.

 

I think too much is made of this. His career before he turned 25 was hardly inspiring: a 1 in 3 record, mostly in the French lower leagues. Since then, he has had two excellent seasons, including his first half season with us, and one poor season. I think the jury is still very much out whether he has what it takes to be a top Premiership striker, or whether he hit a purple patch in his career as many players do at some point. I hope he comes good, I really do, but I fear his spectacular start at the club will always prove hard to live up to.

[Dave]

I'd love it if opposition defenders were as quick to write him off as some Newcastle fans.

 

He had a s*** season last time out but he wasn't helped by being basically our only hope after Ba went (a partnership that Pardew never got working anyway). He's scored goals on a regular basis all his career, with better movement and a greater goal threat from others around him I have little doubt that he'll come good again.

 

I think too much is made of this. His career before he turned 25 was hardly inspiring: a 1 in 3 record, mostly in the French lower leagues. Since then, he has had two excellent seasons, including his first half season with us, and one poor season. I think the jury is still very much out whether he has what it takes to be a top Premiership striker, or whether he hit a purple patch in his career as many players do at some point. I hope he comes good, I really do, but I fear his spectacular start at the club will always prove hard to live up to.

 

I certainly don't think he'll be able to find or maintain that level again, it was ludicrous. But I think he can be a good goalscorer if the team is making chances.

[Guest palnese]

I'd love it if opposition defenders were as quick to write him off as some Newcastle fans.

 

He had a shit season last time out but he wasn't helped by being basically our only hope after Ba went (a partnership that Pardew never got working anyway). He's scored goals on a regular basis all his career, with better movement and a greater goal threat from others around him I have little doubt that he'll come good again.

 

It's not about writing him off, imo, it's about placing him on the bench. He's done nowt this season, and doesn't deserve to start. It's that simple, for me at least.

[TRon]

I'd love it if opposition defenders were as quick to write him off as some Newcastle fans.

 

He had a shit season last time out but he wasn't helped by being basically our only hope after Ba went (a partnership that Pardew never got working anyway). He's scored goals on a regular basis all his career, with better movement and a greater goal threat from others around him I have little doubt that he'll come good again.

 

It's not about writing him off, imo, it's about placing him on the bench. He's done nowt this season, and doesn't deserve to start. It's that simple, for me at least.

 

If we're winning games with him starting, he's not likely to benched just yet.

[Unbelievable]

I'd love it if opposition defenders were as quick to write him off as some Newcastle fans.

 

He had a s*** season last time out but he wasn't helped by being basically our only hope after Ba went (a partnership that Pardew never got working anyway). He's scored goals on a regular basis all his career, with better movement and a greater goal threat from others around him I have little doubt that he'll come good again.

 

I think too much is made of this. His career before he turned 25 was hardly inspiring: a 1 in 3 record, mostly in the French lower leagues. Since then, he has had two excellent seasons, including his first half season with us, and one poor season. I think the jury is still very much out whether he has what it takes to be a top Premiership striker, or whether he hit a purple patch in his career as many players do at some point. I hope he comes good, I really do, but I fear his spectacular start at the club will always prove hard to live up to.

 

I certainly don't think he'll be able to find or maintain that level again, it was ludicrous. But I think he can be a good goalscorer if the team is making chances.

 

Oh I'm not even on about performing at that level consisently, I'm on about being a solid 15+ Premiership goals a season striker, the type any team aiming for Europe needs..

[CPL]

Agree with Dave he's lacking sharpness and his confidence is very low but i would still start him next game.

 

[Unbelievable]

Agree with Dave he's lacking sharpness and his confidence is very low but i would still start him next game.

 

 

I disagree with Dave, but I would still start him next game, how's that? Hurray for squad depth!

[Dave]

I'd love it if opposition defenders were as quick to write him off as some Newcastle fans.

 

He had a s*** season last time out but he wasn't helped by being basically our only hope after Ba went (a partnership that Pardew never got working anyway). He's scored goals on a regular basis all his career, with better movement and a greater goal threat from others around him I have little doubt that he'll come good again.

 

I think too much is made of this. His career before he turned 25 was hardly inspiring: a 1 in 3 record, mostly in the French lower leagues. Since then, he has had two excellent seasons, including his first half season with us, and one poor season. I think the jury is still very much out whether he has what it takes to be a top Premiership striker, or whether he hit a purple patch in his career as many players do at some point. I hope he comes good, I really do, but I fear his spectacular start at the club will always prove hard to live up to.

 

I certainly don't think he'll be able to find or maintain that level again, it was ludicrous. But I think he can be a good goalscorer if the team is making chances.

 

Oh I'm not even on about performing at that level consisently, I'm on about being a solid 15+ Premiership goals a season striker, the one any team aiming for Europe needs..

 

Fortunately we're not aiming for Europe.

 

Nah, I think he could score 15 if the team was doing consistently well.

[Cajun]

Our threat was always going to be from wide areas today. He kept their 2 CBs occupied which freed up space for HBA/Remy/Gouf.

 

He didn't tear up any trees but he was alright.

 

This. Think the trifecta of Remy, Ben Arfa and Cisse will be fantastic so happy to stick with it.

 

Don't see Gouffran as the focal point of a front 3. Think impact sub is his role, as much as he probably deserves a start.

 

What does Cisse provide as that focal point? IMO Gouffran has more to his game and there is nothing that currently sticks out to favour Cisse.

 

Goal threat. You could play Gouffran instead but then Remy would be the main striker, and it might be worth a try at some point. I still see Remy and Cisse as the main strikers and Gouffran as a support striker. Happy to have all three of them here at the moment, we could have done with Gomis as well, but I think we can get goals out of those three.

 

Not at the moment he isn't unfortunately.

 

People talk about the lack of chances being created which is fair but he has to do more himself imo.

 

The Gouffran goal was a good example of this, while Cisse looked like he was in an offside position Gouffran timed his run perfectly, reacted quickly and made sure there was a chance for him to take. Cisse needs to do more of this, there was a chance he had in the first half where the ball was slipped through but he was 5 yards offside before the pass was even made. He plays like he has the pace of Gosling at times where as he could probably compete with most centre backs pace wise.

 

It can't be argued against that we don't make bundles of chances but he needs to help himself too.

[TRon]

The good thing is that we now have the option of resting him when it's required because Remy and Gouffran would certainly be a decent alternative pair. But Pardew would need to show better rotation policy than he did while Ba was here.

[TRon]

Our threat was always going to be from wide areas today. He kept their 2 CBs occupied which freed up space for HBA/Remy/Gouf.

 

He didn't tear up any trees but he was alright.

 

This. Think the trifecta of Remy, Ben Arfa and Cisse will be fantastic so happy to stick with it.

 

Don't see Gouffran as the focal point of a front 3. Think impact sub is his role, as much as he probably deserves a start.

 

What does Cisse provide as that focal point? IMO Gouffran has more to his game and there is nothing that currently sticks out to favour Cisse.

 

Goal threat. You could play Gouffran instead but then Remy would be the main striker, and it might be worth a try at some point. I still see Remy and Cisse as the main strikers and Gouffran as a support striker. Happy to have all three of them here at the moment, we could have done with Gomis as well, but I think we can get goals out of those three.

 

Not at the moment he isn't unfortunately.

 

People talk about the lack of chances being created which is fair but he has to do more himself imo.

 

The Gouffran goal was a good example of this, while Cisse looked like he was in an offside position Gouffran timed his run perfectly, reacted quickly and made sure there was a chance for him to take. Cisse needs to do more of this, there was a chance he had in the first half where the ball was slipped through but he was 5 yards offside before the pass was even made. He plays like he has the pace of Gosling at times where as he could probably compete with most centre backs pace wise.

 

It can't be argued against that we don't make bundles of chances but he needs to help himself too.

 

That's just my personal opinion of Cisse vs Gouffran as out and out strikers. It's not going to look too clever at the moment, but I still see a striker who will score goals this season in Cisse.

[Cajun]

Our threat was always going to be from wide areas today. He kept their 2 CBs occupied which freed up space for HBA/Remy/Gouf.

 

He didn't tear up any trees but he was alright.

 

This. Think the trifecta of Remy, Ben Arfa and Cisse will be fantastic so happy to stick with it.

 

Don't see Gouffran as the focal point of a front 3. Think impact sub is his role, as much as he probably deserves a start.

 

What does Cisse provide as that focal point? IMO Gouffran has more to his game and there is nothing that currently sticks out to favour Cisse.

 

Goal threat. You could play Gouffran instead but then Remy would be the main striker, and it might be worth a try at some point. I still see Remy and Cisse as the main strikers and Gouffran as a support striker. Happy to have all three of them here at the moment, we could have done with Gomis as well, but I think we can get goals out of those three.

 

Not at the moment he isn't unfortunately.

 

People talk about the lack of chances being created which is fair but he has to do more himself imo.

 

The Gouffran goal was a good example of this, while Cisse looked like he was in an offside position Gouffran timed his run perfectly, reacted quickly and made sure there was a chance for him to take. Cisse needs to do more of this, there was a chance he had in the first half where the ball was slipped through but he was 5 yards offside before the pass was even made. He plays like he has the pace of Gosling at times where as he could probably compete with most centre backs pace wise.

 

It can't be argued against that we don't make bundles of chances but he needs to help himself too.

 

That's just my personal opinion of Cisse vs Gouffran as out and out strikers. It's not going to look too clever at the moment, but I still see a striker who will score goals this season in Cisse.

 

 

I don't go along with this purple patch thing but I do believe if Cisse starts and everyone is fit then a better performing player is going to be benched.

[Gallowgate Toon]

Torn on him, I do think he'd benefit from a bit of time in a team playing relatively well but Gouffran's really making a great case to be starting.