Jump to content

Everton 2 - 2 Newcastle United - 17/09/12 - post-match reaction from page 57


Recommended Posts

Harper 5 - probably should have done better for the first goal but his save for the "goal" was amazing. Distribution is shocking too.

 

Perch 5 - abysmally poor in the first, was a lot better when moved in to the middle.

Williamson 4- piss poor

Taylor 4 - piss poor

Santon 6 - decent but didn't really have much to do.

 

Marveaux 3 - anonymous

Jonas 5 - terrible in the first, decent in the second

Anita 5 - as above

Cabaye 6 - as above but +1 for assisting

HBA 5 - should have scored, a lot of frustrated dribbling/tricks which didn't come off.

 

Cisse 4 - did fuck all, barely held it up but the service was shocking

 

SUBS

Ba 9 - superb, two brilliant takes, game changer

Shola 8 - one touch of note and what a good one it was.

Bigi - n/a

 

You can't really do a ratings for tonight, considering each 45 minutes were like a completely different match for the majority of players.

 

Ridiculously harsh on Steven Taylor, either way.

 

Let Anichebe turn him for the goal, was the one who played Fellaini offside for the incorrectly disallowed goal and had a couple of other moments one where he played Anichebe onside which was fucking ridiculous.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harper 5 - probably should have done better for the first goal but his save for the "goal" was amazing. Distribution is shocking too.

 

Perch 5 - abysmally poor in the first, was a lot better when moved in to the middle.

Williamson 4- piss poor

Taylor 4 - piss poor

Santon 6 - decent but didn't really have much to do.

 

Marveaux 3 - anonymous

Jonas 5 - terrible in the first, decent in the second

Anita 5 - as above

Cabaye 6 - as above but +1 for assisting

HBA 5 - should have scored, a lot of frustrated dribbling/tricks which didn't come off.

 

Cisse 4 - did fuck all, barely held it up but the service was shocking

 

SUBS

Ba 9 - superb, two brilliant takes, game changer

Shola 8 - one touch of note and what a good one it was.

Bigi - n/a

 

You can't really do a ratings for tonight, considering each 45 minutes were like a completely different match for the majority of players.

 

Ridiculously harsh on Steven Taylor, either way.

 

Let Anichebe turn him for the goal, was the one who played Fellaini offside for the incorrectly disallowed goal and had a couple of other moments one where he played Anichebe onside which was fucking ridiculous.

 

:thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Feeling kinda bad for the linesman. He's going to get a lot of shit and both of the errors were so close that you just can't see those with human eye. Goalline technology is a must.

 

Indeed, shouldn't even have to worry about looking out for whether the ball crosses or not.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly Anita really deserves praise. His pace meant Baines couldn't get in behind any more.

 

Baines was a ghost in the second half, Anita had him locked up.

 

Anyway what is baffling me is every game this season we have been utter crap in the first half and great/much improved in the 2nd half.

 

Why can't we just start well for once lol.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Neville spot on about the offside IMO.

 

what he say?

 

 

 

turned stream off. it was running few mins behind- couldnt fking believe my eyes when they went 2-1 up, and came on here to cry and it was 2-2. :lol:

 

Basically said it was technically offside, but that his initial reaction at the time was 'offside' (as was mine) and it was so marginal at full speed that it wasn't nearly as clear as when you're stopping the replay with split-second accuracy. That he could totally understand it being ruled out.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harper 5 - probably should have done better for the first goal but his save for the "goal" was amazing. Distribution is shocking too.

 

Perch 5 - abysmally poor in the first, was a lot better when moved in to the middle.

Williamson 4- piss poor

Taylor 4 - piss poor

Santon 6 - decent but didn't really have much to do.

 

Marveaux 3 - anonymous

Jonas 5 - terrible in the first, decent in the second

Anita 5 - as above

Cabaye 6 - as above but +1 for assisting

HBA 5 - should have scored, a lot of frustrated dribbling/tricks which didn't come off.

 

Cisse 4 - did fuck all, barely held it up but the service was shocking

 

SUBS

Ba 9 - superb, two brilliant takes, game changer

Shola 8 - one touch of note and what a good one it was.

Bigi - n/a

 

Santon was very decent I thought, other than that - not far wrong. Sympathy with the players first half for doing (trying to do :lol:) defensive work they're clearly not equipped for.

 

Think Saylor was better than Willy too

Link to post
Share on other sites

Neville spot on about the offside IMO.

 

what he say?

 

 

 

turned stream off. it was running few mins behind- couldnt fking believe my eyes when they went 2-1 up, and came on here to cry and it was 2-2. :lol:

 

Basically said it was technically offside, but that his initial reaction at the time was 'offside' (as was mine) and it was so marginal at full speed that it wasn't nearly as clear as when you're stopping the replay with split-second accuracy.

Aye, bang on that :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Other than the Mackems and Liverpool, after the pre-match breeze from their camp there's no team I'd rather spawn a point off than them.

 

Now, I can go back to cheering them on. Those plucky midtable scrappers, bless 'em. ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Their keeper should be shot for his 'challenge' on Ba btw. If I was Niel, I'd be having nightmares about that tonight.

 

He's done it before against Kevin Doyle, jumped thinking he'd lob it but Doyle just rolled it under him.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest bimpy474

Highway robbery to get a point in that game, and what an awesome game it was! Great for the neutral viewer.

 

Eh ?. First half aside (Cisse should have scored and a clearance of the line) . The second half we could have scored 4 ourselves.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...