Paul Dummett

[TRon]

1 hour ago, Dokko said:

 

If he could be fit for 75% of the season then aye. But it's more like 25% and it's a waste of a squad place especially in the summer when we can go and get players who are not always broken. 

 

Exactly this. I don't have that much of a problem with his abilities, he's no world beater but can do a job as a stand in. But why would you want to hand out another contract to an ageing, injury prone player?

[Conjo]

40 minutes ago, gbandit said:

has almost never put in a really poor defensive performance. 

 

I'm not going to fact check that, but my gut feeling is that this is re-writing history. I'm sure he's had a lot of woeful performances, even defensively. Had a good little spell under Rafa, and a few games under Bruce but other than that his defensive qualities has mostly been judged on the odd admittedly impressive recovery run and subsequent sliding tackle, literally the only redeeming quality he has, and now he's not even doing that.

[Thiago]

I trust Howe's judgement, but right now I'd need to see an improvement to justify it. He may just be rusty after such a long time out, but even then, he was very much a defensive fullback with minimal attacking output. That's fine when playing with ASM, but right now I'm hoping Targett plays the rest of the season.

[gbandit]

@Conjoit’s not a hill I’m willing to die on as I checked out of watching our games under Bruce but I don’t remember games where he defended very poorly under Rafa

[xLiaaamx]

I'd rather sign Targett and someone else than keep Dummett now. I'd rather have Lewis and still would rather have Lewis available now personally. 

[ponsaelius]

We're probably going to struggle to shift some of our deadwood this summer who are still contracted - the likes of Dummett who are actually out of contract (while also not good enough and always injured) should surely be first out the door.

[MrRaspberryJam]

Been a steady player for us, but time to offload. 

[arnonel]

Steady as a CB in a 3, but Championship level at best as a LB

[Andymc1]

20 hours ago, HUGZ said:

might sound harsh, but I fucking hate him (as a footballer, not as a person) and can't wait until he gets peddled  him being our benchmark is a big reason Matt Targett looked like prime Cafu on his debut.

 

He's never, ever been good enough. people argue he's a good defender, and does the fundamentals well, but he's shit scared of the ball, has zero technique and offers no attacking threat whatsoever. because he's so limited he gets held to the lowest possible standard, the opposite of someone like ASM, basically. not to mention he's a perma crock.

 

thanks for everything Paul, but down to the Champo you go son. Bruce will probably sign him. which says everything you need to know.

 

100% this  

[joeyt]

 

Pray for @Optimistic Nut

[Kanj]

Would rather see him retire and be a coach in the lower setup. Rafa mentioned multiple times he seems Paul going into management because he's a really good footbal mind.

Hating him @HUGZ is so harsh  . You and @Optimistic Nut should be high fiving that post. 

[Sima]

Would be a huge mistake.  He’s shite and a crock.

 

 

Edited February 22, 2022 by Sima

[Disco]

Insane if he manages to rob another contract. 

[PauloGeordio]

19 minutes ago, Disco said:

Insane if he manages to rob another contract. 

True, but after this summers business we won’t give a hoot 

[midds]

I would never have thought about extending his contract without a takeover. The thought of spending decent money to upgrade on him is automatic. It's little shit like this that just starts to gently stir a few doubts about Howe's judgement if he's even thinking about doing this.  

[Kid Icarus]

As an aside from what you think of Dummett as a player, or how re-signing Paul Dummett flies in the face of aiming to win the PL in 5-10 years, his injury record alone is enough to say giving him another contract is insane. 

[Thiago]

Part of me wonders if any of this is just keeping folk happy until the season is over.

[M1tche]

Abit of a random thought, but maybe its not a playing contract that he is going to be offered.

[tgarve]

1 hour ago, M1tche said:

Abit of a random thought, but maybe its not a playing contract that he is going to be offered.

 

director of football? 

[Mazzy]

All 3 of those tipped to get new contracts won't he playing a huge amount of league football next season I don't think.

 

Next season they will add depth and experience into a squad that will be made up of alot of players from abroad who have never played in the Premier League. They'll get alot of minutes in Cup competitions and if we are in dire need Die to injuries.

[Theregulars]

I’m not even convinced by the “need a squad” argument. One of the many players who have played for us during the Ashley years who you can’t conceivably see playing at another premier league side.

[HawK]

Ticks the homegrown-at-club box, not many of ours do, and is happy to be a squad player who Howe & co seemingly like. No argument from me.

[Geordie Ahmed]

Shelvey and Schar have shown to be more than useful under Howe so them getting a new contract makes sense 

 

Dummett if he wasn't always injured wouldn't be bad to have around but we know he's guaranteed an injury 

 

It could as someone suggested just be a tactic of Howe to ensure the squad is united until the end of the season

 

I like Dummett but him getting a new contract isn't a sign of progression 

[HaydnNUFC]

He should be moved on. He'd be okay as emergency cover but he's barely ever fit enough to be even that. Only logical reason I can think of for an extension is the homegrown at club squad registration rules, don't think we have many.

[et tu brute]

9 minutes ago, Geordie Ahmed said:

Shelvey and Schar have shown to be more than useful under Howe so them getting a new contract makes sense 

 

Dummett if he wasn't always injured wouldn't be bad to have around but we know he's guaranteed an injury 

 

It could as someone suggested just be a tactic of Howe to ensure the squad is united until the end of the season

 

I like Dummett but him getting a new contract isn't a sign of progression 

Don’t think Shelvey makes sense imo, when he has another year left after this one. If he’s still performing ok next Christmas time then fair enough. He’s been here years and has been total shit for most of that time, so has to do a level performance over a much longer period to convince me. 
 

No chance in hell would I give Dummett a new contract, as not only is he an injury liability, he’s also a pretty average premier league player. As I mentioned in another thread, it’s an Edwards article, so take with a pinch of salt anyway.