Jump to content

Jack Colback (now a free agent)


Recommended Posts

Impressive to be able to do all that running and still be totally off the pace and out of position so you have to get booked all the time.

 

This is simply it. He's running around to no effect.

 

Also, why doesn't he pass the ball forward? He's terribly over cautious.

 

De Jong hardly received the ball to feet in that last game, because both he and Anita, kept going sideways and back to bloody Williamson of all people, who then hoofed.

 

This has been going on for years now. We have an attacking midfielder playing off the front man. Can we please try and get him the ball?! So he has a chance to influence the game.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Who covers our totally inept back 4 between Wijnaldum and Sissoko then ?

 

Ideally Abeid if he's as good as he showed before he got injured, if not we'll probably need to buy someone as I'm not convinced Anita is the answer. Plus Colback is no DM as he doesn’t have the discipline for it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd prefer Anita covering the back 4 over Colback like, but that's why we need a new midfielder. I've never been sold on Sissoko's ability to play deep but apparently he was mint at it in France?

 

Yes, ultimately we need just one of them in there. It's painful watching them both side by side.

 

Colback has to then take the blame more, because he is not supposed to be a holding mid, so not sure why he is so negative.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd prefer Anita covering the back 4 over Colback like, but that's why we need a new midfielder. I've never been sold on Sissoko's ability to play deep but apparently he was mint at it in France?

 

The thing about Anita covering the back 4 is he can actually tackle. With Colback the ball's been and gone long before he lunges in with a pashun challenge.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He's probably as bad as Tiote for fouls in stupid areas, just he does it in a stupid niggly way rather than Tiote mistiming a tackle.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd prefer Anita covering the back 4 over Colback like, but that's why we need a new midfielder. I've never been sold on Sissoko's ability to play deep but apparently he was mint at it in France?

 

The thing about Anita covering the back 4 is he can actually tackle. With Colback the ball's been and gone long before he lunges in with a pashun challenge.

 

I hope Anita  plays a much bigger role under SM this season. Our midfield was so disjointed last season and all a bit of a mess, if SM finds a good balance and style with Wijnaldum/De Jong, Anita would revel in the role sitting behind them imo.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest reefatoon

And you think Anita will solve that? He is as shite as the rest of them, there is absolutely no way Anita is going to make a difference to our midfield. He doesn't do nearly enough to make a difference. Good to have your nonsense back on here though Brett, you have been a miss!

Link to post
Share on other sites

And you think Anita will solve that? He is as shite as the rest of them, there is absolutely no way Anita is going to make a difference to our midfield. He doesn't do nearly enough to make a difference. Good to have your nonsense back on here though Brett, you have been a miss!

 

Well I think I agree with Kaka, Anita is only useful if he's the ONLY defensive midfielder. When you put him alongside Tiote or Colback they just end up getting in each other's way, but that is how the dream team of Pards & Charver lined them up.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Playing in a system that suits him along with players he knows well would absolutely benefit him as a player. He's so undervalued because many of his performances have been poor, but playing hoofball with Vurnon Anita in your team is really just going to be like Peter Crouch and Lacina Traore playing piggy in the middle with Verne Troyer.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest reefatoon

I just don't really buy into the hype he gets . It is all if's and but's with him.  I just don't rate players that have to have other or specific players around them for them to make a difference (which he still doesn't really).  He needs to start showing something radically different for me to put him out of the category of bang average midfielders, like the majority we have. If we could replace him with someone who offers more than just something tidy (hate that word for a midfielder, as so much more is needed) then I would be all for it. I just don't see him being any kind of answer off past performances.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I just don't really buy into the hype he gets . It is all if's and but's with him.  I just don't rate players that have to have other or specific players around them for them to make a difference (which he still doesn't really).  He needs to start showing something radically different for me to put him out of the category of bang average midfielders, like the majority we have. If we could replace him with someone who offers more than just something tidy (hate that word for a midfielder, as so much more is needed) then I would be all for it. I just don't see him being any kind of answer off past performances.

 

One thing I'm looking forward to this season is seeing how our underperforming players do under the new coaches. Whilst I accept Pardew and his thick mates have a lot to answer for, I don't accept (as quite a few on here seem to) that every player who has played poorly is a direct result of poor coaching and nothing else. I'm hoping the likes of Anita will show a little more this season before we run out of excuses for them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I just don't really buy into the hype he gets . It is all if's and but's with him.  I just don't rate players that have to have other or specific players around them for them to make a difference (which he still doesn't really).  He needs to start showing something radically different for me to put him out of the category of bang average midfielders, like the majority we have. If we could replace him with someone who offers more than just something tidy (hate that word for a midfielder, as so much more is needed) then I would be all for it. I just don't see him being any kind of answer off past performances.

 

It depends on what your expectations are of a defensive midfielder. I would have thought his main job is to protect the back 4, break up play and then pass the ball quickly. I think he's got the tools to do that, and he did it brilliantly against West Ham in the final game of the season.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Impressive to be able to do all that running and still be totally off the pace and out of position so you have to get booked all the time.

 

Similar number of yellows to Wanyama, Matic, Mason, Fabregas etc. It's the nature of the role.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Those players are not out of position as often as Colback is though, well Fabregas might be but he gives you near 20 assists going the other way so who cares really.

 

I'll leave it there though, it's pretty clear where we all stand on this subject no point repeating it over and over.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fabregas has a phenomenal team around him and Colback has nowt but drivel either side of him, he was our leading goalscorer from midfield and I'm sure he got more assists than any other midfielder in the team last season too. I'm certainly not trying to say he's a good player and he should start but I find the amount of people absolutely smashing him to pieces on here a bit odd.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fabregas has a phenomenal team around him and Colback has nowt but drivel either side of him, he was our leading goalscorer from midfield and I'm sure he got more assists than any other midfielder in the team last season too. I'm certainly not trying to say he's a good player and he should start but I find the amount of people absolutely smashing him to pieces on here a bit odd.

 

Sissoko.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fabregas has a phenomenal team around him and Colback has nowt but drivel either side of him, he was our leading goalscorer from midfield and I'm sure he got more assists than any other midfielder in the team last season too. I'm certainly not trying to say he's a good player and he should start but I find the amount of people absolutely smashing him to pieces on here a bit odd.

 

Sissoko.

 

Yeah, whatever. He got the most fantasy league points last season so gan on Capt. Jack. :la:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...