Scott McTominay

[Stal]

1 minute ago, Froggy said:

 

More of a PSR asset than a cast off in reality. 

 

Probably, but still didn't want him after smith, butt, obertan etc

[Froggy]

9 minutes ago, Stal said:

Probably, but still didn't want him after smith, butt, obertan etc

 

Harsh on Butt. 

[Hanshithispantz]

3 minutes ago, Froggy said:

 

Harsh on Butt. 

[Roids]

Watched this dude for almost a decade in the Prem, he's not a good player. 

  

Congrats on whatever improvements he may be showing in Italy but let's relax on the revisionism.

 

Not long before someone suggests we should sign Anthony.

[Roids]

4 hours ago, TheDarkKnight said:

 

Trawl my posts.

 

Scotland fan here.

 

I told you all that Scott McTominay wasn't a no 6. I said that his best attribute was finishing and I told you that Newcastle should've signed him.

 

I was mocked.

 

I remember someone here saying that he was a league 2 player

 

Yeah. Well. That "league 2 player" is on the cusp of winning Serie A and winning the player of the year award.

 

All the best.

 

This is sad if true, that league used to boast the likes of R9, Crespo, Shevchenko, Seedorf, Adriano to name but a few.

 

What a tragic falloff.

[ponsaelius]

He hasn't been that good this season really in terms of general play. But he does have a very good eye for stealing goals when played a bit further forward.

 

I was never down on signing him personally. Definitely think he would have been a very good fourth midfielder to strengthen that area as would Gallagher have been who people were equally not convinced on.

 

However he is not really the right age profile nor would he have been a game changing signing.

 

 

Edited 2 hours ago by ponsaelius

[Kimbo]

Surely we would’ve had to sell someone to buy him last summer anyway? Unless we’re talking about the previous year when we bought Tonali, should we have got McTominay instead?

[The Butcher]

Isn't he just a more mobile Kevin Nolan?

[Roids]

13 minutes ago, The Butcher said:

Isn't he just a more mobile Kevin Nolan?

Much more athletic otherwise less talented (technique/finishing/game sense)

 

 

Edited 2 hours ago by Roids

[WilliamPS]

16 minutes ago, The Butcher said:

Isn't he just a more mobile Kevin Nolan?

A mobile Kevin Nolan is like an oxymoron - I just can’t imagine K-No getting round the pitch at speed. 

[Kanj]

I just think it’s good to see the player enjoying his football and doing well under a proper coach. Too often players are written off very quickly when they may perhaps be in an awful situation destined to do very little. See Longstaff under Bruce. 

[Rich]

I admire your pettiness game, TheDarkKnight. Got to take any win you can when you support Scotland and Man Utd, I suppose.

[Shays Given Tim Flowers]

1 minute ago, Rich said:

I admire your pettiness game, TheDarkKnight. Got to take any win you can when you support Scotland and Man Utd, I suppose.

Even with the pettiness he’s still nowhere near the worst Man Utd fan on the forum.