Jump to content

Man United 0 - 0 Newcastle United - 22/08/15 - Post-match reaction from page 39


BlueStar

Recommended Posts

Watched the game in bits and pieces during a family BBQ.

 

Thought NUFC's fitness was really bad. For most of the second half it seemed as though the players had all been asked to play with their weaker foot. Most clearances barely made it out of the box. Thauvin seemed to be running on fumes despite being a sub which was weird.

 

NUFC didn't seem set up to have a go - it actually seemed particularly aimless but for some individual talent on show - noticeably Perez, Haidara and Mitrovic who tried to make things happen. I thought Mbemba really grew into the game but I thought Colo was very, very lucky on a few occasions. Didn't agree with the MotM choice whatsoever.

 

Mitrovic seemed very isolated but I found it brilliant that we had a centre forward who was bothering their defenders and letting them know they were in a game. His footwork seems a bit clunky so far, but so did most out there. A lot of work to be done.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It was a good point but not the brilliant performance some are making it out to be. Man Utd are absolutely bobbins. We invited far too much pressure in the second half and could have relieved some of that by actually having a go. I've got a feeling I'm not gonna like McClaren's substitutions. :lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites

We got of jail given the 1st 15 minutes today. MU were so pedestrian once we got sorted out they made us look organised. For all the plaudits being handed out, rerun those those opening minutes and have a think what teams with more urgency will do to us.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Must have been a very disciplined performance after a dodgy start by the sounds of it.

or maybe Man u are just a bit shit as well.

 

Good point without a doubt.

 

Sounds like Taylor had his obligatory one good game...injured/sent off/gives penalty away next outing no doubt.

 

If he can get right blend of our forward/creative players, and get them all fit, we will worry sides going forward imo

Width the key to providing Mitrovic?

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

hopefully, with perez' performance and thauvin's cameo, that should see the end of obertan.

he found himself in decent positions but had neither the brains or the balls to do anything.

 

Today was far from one of Obertans worst performances imo. Made a few good interceptions/tackles and at least tried to use his pace on the counter. No doubt he is not good enough but was far from his worst today like.

 

Is this a genuine opinion? He was absolutely horrible, his positioning defensively was crap and he just doesn't seem to care while also lacking a brain.

Link to post
Share on other sites

hopefully, with perez' performance and thauvin's cameo, that should see the end of obertan.

he found himself in decent positions but had neither the brains or the balls to do anything.

 

Today was far from one of Obertans worst performances imo. Made a few good interceptions/tackles and at least tried to use his pace on the counter. No doubt he is not good enough but was far from his worst today like.

 

Is this a genuine opinion? He was absolutely horrible, his positioning defensively was crap and he just doesn't seem to care while also lacking a brain.

 

Summed up nicely in one sentence. :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Nah it wasn't crap. We couldn't have defended the way we did without him doing what he did. He's not a favourite, maybe shouldn't have stated, I wouldn't start him but to say his performance was absolutely horrible is crap.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you bring back Janmaat after such a decent back 4 performance as that? Think if someone is dropped it would be harsh, especially since Janmaat has start the season in neutral.

 

Also think that's the end of us looking at defenders.

Link to post
Share on other sites

You could say that Man Utd didn't play well, but you could look at it as a case of us knowing Man Utd wouldn't press us much and us playing to suit that. Not many teams are going to go to OT and play Man Utd off the park, the top 4 aside you wouldn't expect I t to happen. We played well, yes the first 15 minutes was poor but that was mostly down to our errors rather than Man Utd. The game is played over 90 minutes and we did well enough to get a point over those 90 minutes, so stop with all the talk of what happened in the first 15 minutes.

Link to post
Share on other sites

While saylor and colo did well was ideal type of game for them with all teh deep defending. Would want mbemba back at Cb if we are seeking to dominate a game. Next week is arsenal even if its at home it is a possibility as likely we will be playing on the break again

Link to post
Share on other sites

Obertan was awful. Always made the wrong decision when his full back was 2 on 1. Offered poor cover. Offensively made poor decisions giving the ball back to manure. Defensive performance was despite him, surely can't start the next game

Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you bring back Janmaat after such a decent back 4 performance as that? Think if someone is dropped it would be harsh, especially since Janmaat has start the season in neutral.

 

Also think that's the end of us looking at defenders.

 

Janmaat shouldn't walk straight back into the team, players coming in should be motivated by knowing a good game keeps them in the team.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you bring back Janmaat after such a decent back 4 performance as that? Think if someone is dropped it would be harsh, especially since Janmaat has start the season in neutral.

 

Also think that's the end of us looking at defenders.

 

Janmaat shouldn't walk straight back into the team, players coming in should be motivated by knowing a good game keeps them in the team.

Keep Taylor in then and Mbemba at right back  ?
Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you bring back Janmaat after such a decent back 4 performance as that? Think if someone is dropped it would be harsh, especially since Janmaat has start the season in neutral.

 

Also think that's the end of us looking at defenders.

 

Janmaat shouldn't walk straight back into the team, players coming in should be motivated by knowing a good game keeps them in the team.

 

can understand that as well

Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep Taylor in then and Mbemba at right back  ?

 

I would after today and I was totally against us lining up that way.  I hate seeing players doing well and getting dropped just because another player comes back unless the player coming back is a player you can't do without.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep Taylor in then and Mbemba at right back  ?

 

I would after today and I was totally against us lining up that way.  I hate seeing players doing well and getting dropped just because another player comes back unless the player coming back is a player you can't do without.

Know what you mean but I just don't know. I'd like Taylor in against Giroud but want Janmaat to get forward,Colo's reading of the game needs to be there for the way Arsenal play. Nice to have choices!

 

(And Williamson never mentioned once in those posts)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thought that was a decent enough showing today. Was worth it seeing the frustration of all the cockney reds squirming in Westfield Stratford. Like poked far more resolute defensively. We surrender the midfield ridiculously easily; the slow bros in the middle with the pea heart of marrow heed makes for poor viewing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...