Sean Longstaff

[joeyt]

Remember when he was apparently worth 5 times that

[toontownman]

In fairness to both the Longstaffs no one could have predicted Bruce would last this long. They probably hoped they would either get to play under someone competent here or the takeover would have happened.

 

As it is they both just need to get out of dodge if they want top be playing at the top level in the future.

 

Thought Sean looked decent in his cameo on Sunday. There is a player there in both cases but we won't see it under this regime. Go before it's too late.

[KaKa]

God ... if this guy goes to Everton and returns to the top form he found with Rafa back in the day. It would be so incredibly enjoyable to see Bruce squirm about it when it comes up 

[mrmojorisin75]

£10m

 

I know it's silly money across the board but anyone paying that after his last two years that isn't Rafa needs putting down

[Guest]

We’d probably get Davies on loan in return.

[Kanj]

That fucking injury he got man, he would have carried that form on too. 

[HaydnNUFC]

He's been terrible for a while now, mind. That performance away at Leeds last season was AIDS inducing, two of his set plays were so bad they led to breaks which Leeds scored twice from.  

 

A better manager like Benitez would get more from him, or any player of ours for that matter tbh. But I've seen nowt since March 2019(!) since he picked up his injury to suggest those 8 games were anything but a purple patch. Yes, the common difference between those 8 games and the 2 seasons since was the manager, but surely we would've seen a positive glimpse since then? We may have done but nothing whatsoever springs to mind.

 

After his form over the last 2 seasons I'd cash in tbh for £10m+ if it means we get a suitable replacement. (  )

[Ketsbaia]

He did nowt before turning 21, had a small purple patch and nothing since. Obviously the latter part is likely down to Bruce but I certainly wouldn't miss the guy.

 

We just don't know if he's any good.

[Holmesy]

Quality CMs command a premium and managers will have seen enough of him under Rafa to think he’s worth the risk. Age is on his side and he’s shown he can run games at this level with the right coaching. We’re about as far from that as you can get so let him see if he can fulfil his potential elsewhere instead of rotting under Bruce

[Thumbheed]

1 hour ago, HaydnNUFC said:

He's been terrible for a while now, mind. That performance away at Leeds last season was AIDS inducing, two of his set plays were so bad they led to breaks which Leeds scored twice from.  

 

A better manager like Benitez would get more from him, or any player of ours for that matter tbh. But I've seen nowt since March 2019(!) since he picked up his injury to suggest those 8 games were anything but a purple patch. Yes, the common difference between those 8 games and the 2 seasons since was the manager, but surely we would've seen a positive glimpse since then? We may have done but nothing whatsoever springs to mind.

 

After his form over the last 2 seasons I'd cash in tbh for £10m+ if it means we get a suitable replacement. (  )

He has been poor but I do wonder which midfielder whose main asset is his passing ability would thrive in a team with little movement, direction and positional awareness?

 

A pass is only as good as the movement and the positioning of the players that are receiving the pass and it's fair to say we've had none of that the past 2 seasons. 

 

I also don't think it's a coincidence that our most affective midfielders have players who are good ball carriers or players who break up play as neither skills are dependent on the movement of other players so for me it's far too premature to write him off now. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited August 18, 2021 by Thumbheed

[HaydnNUFC]

14 minutes ago, Thumbheed said:

He has been poor but I do wonder which midfielder whose main asset is his passing ability would thrive in a team with little movement, direction and positional awareness?

 

A pass is only as good as the movement and the positioning of the players that are receiving the pass and it's fair to say we've had none of that the past 2 seasons. 

 

I also don't think it's a coincidence that our most affective midfielders have players who are good ball carriers or players who break up play as neither skills are dependent on the movement of other players so for me it's far too premature to write him off now. 

 

I get what you're saying but someone could easily use that argument as to why Shelvey looks largely piss poor in this team rather than he's just shit. I've not seen any glimpses from him to suggest he's a good footballer at this level since the start of 2019-20 and that was some time ago. Maybe Man United (h) when his brother scored the winner? But even then it was his brother who was getting the deserved praise and Matty's the poor bastard who never gets played!  

 

I've watched the highlights of Leeds away last season to jog my memory and he's responsible for three of their goals. Three. 

 

I suppose I need more convincing and I'm not sure that it's gonna be here. A £10m+ move would probably be best for all parties, especially if it means Matty finally gets his chance in the team again. I doubt it though.

[et tu brute]

1 hour ago, HaydnNUFC said:

He's been terrible for a while now, mind. That performance away at Leeds last season was AIDS inducing, two of his set plays were so bad they led to breaks which Leeds scored twice from.  

 

A better manager like Benitez would get more from him, or any player of ours for that matter tbh. But I've seen nowt since March 2019(!) since he picked up his injury to suggest those 8 games were anything but a purple patch. Yes, the common difference between those 8 games and the 2 seasons since was the manager, but surely we would've seen a positive glimpse since then? We may have done but nothing whatsoever springs to mind.

 

After his form over the last 2 seasons I'd cash in tbh for £10m+ if it means we get a suitable replacement. (  )

I’m always a big believer that if you are a player of a good quality standard then you will still see that on a football pitch no matter who the manager is. Yes a player will perform better at more frequent levels under a better manager, but you don’t just go to a shit level of performance over a two year period under a poor manager. You still see quality players like Wilson and St Max giving high level performances under the same poor manager. If Everton or anyone else offered 10 million, personally I would bite their hand off. 

 

 

Edited August 19, 2021 by et tu brute

[Superior Acuña]

 

i'd like to see Sean go. There could be a decent player in there and it's a shame to see him waste away. Given our state I'm less concerned about us getting the benefit and am just  sad to see a decent geordie player not make the most of his career.

[Conjo]

At nearly 24 time is definitely not on his side. Players that hasn't properly broken through by that time are extremely unlikely to do so. A handful of good performances during a spell that lasted 2-3 months back in first half of 2019 is most likely looking like that, a good spell for a very average player that was playing in a well drilled team that was in good form. There's other players I'd like to see go before him, but we don't have the luxury to pick and chose whom to sell, so if anyone is willing to give £10m for him I'd say that's good money* based on the last two seasons.

 

*for a team that would invest the money again to improve the team.

[GWN]

I agree , this shite that Rafa will sort him out is a slap in the face of fans for his poor performance of recent times.He looks like he has no desire to play for the shirt , to want to succeed , I’d cash in now before he becomes worthless .He’s bang average , even under Rafa nothing special like his brother in truth , sell them both or they need to step up and perform like they want the shirt.

It’s down to them .

 

 

Edited August 19, 2021 by GWN

[Paully]

He needs to go to Everton and work under a proper coach, sadly for us

[Paully]

“This has been a Michael Carrick-type performance,” Martin Keown declared enthusiastically. “A lot of people are talking about Declan Rice at West Ham, but I think this lad might be better.”

 

https://theathletic.com/2764262/2021/08/18/sean-longstaff-the-one-time-50m-midfielder-who-needs-to-leave-newcastle/

[GWN]

3 minutes ago, Paully said:

He needs to go to Everton and work under a proper coach, sadly for us

So if he stays he’s thieving a living ? Can our current coaching set up not get it out of him? I really do get this comment mate just wondering why can’t Sean just knuckle down and prove he’s a top player .

[Paully]

10 minutes ago, GWN said:

So if he stays he’s thieving a living ? Can our current coaching set up not get it out of him? I really do get this comment mate just wondering why can’t Sean just knuckle down and prove he’s a top player .

 

Thieving a living? WTF?

 

The current "manager" is utterly clueless and Longstaff looked a top player under Rafa and seemingly Everton want him and he's a free agent in the summer. If I was him, it's a no-brainer.

[Guest]

He’d not be first choice but it’d be a damn sight better being on the bench behind Allan & Doucoure with Benitez as manager compared to being behind Hayden & Shelvey with Bruce managing you.

[Cronky]

Wherever he ends up, he now needs to be playing regular first team football.

[Thumbheed]

8 hours ago, HaydnNUFC said:

 

I get what you're saying but someone could easily use that argument as to why Shelvey looks largely piss poor in this team rather than he's just shit. I've not seen any glimpses from him to suggest he's a good footballer at this level since the start of 2019-20 and that was some time ago. Maybe Man United (h) when his brother scored the winner? But even then it was his brother who was getting the deserved praise and Matty's the poor bastard who never gets played!  

 

I've watched the highlights of Leeds away last season to jog my memory and he's responsible for three of their goals. Three. 

 

I suppose I need more convincing and I'm not sure that it's gonna be here. A £10m+ move would probably be best for all parties, especially if it means Matty finally gets his chance in the team again. I doubt it though.

 

I predict we'll see a lot more praise for Shelvey this year and that will be despite his glaring limitations as a player. 

 

I dont think that will be because he's suddenly shown himself to be a good player but because the tactics will bring out his best asset. 

 

My belief is once you show yourself to be a good player, then you always have that in you and there's only 2 or 3 things which stop you from getting that to those same heights; tactics, mentality and injuries. At 24 I don't think his injury will be the things that's holding him back as much as tactics and confidence.

 

I bet there's a lot of people who advocate selling him who will also be saying that someone like Rafa can get the best out of him, which is a bit of a paradox, no? 

 

I honestly hope he gets some game time in the position Shelvey played on Sunday.

[GWN]

Just to be clear I wouldn’t sell him IF he wants it enough here .

[Minhosa]

11 minutes ago, GWN said:

Just to be clear I wouldn’t sell him IF he wants it enough here .

Enough? Enough to put up with a useless cunt of a manager who's essentially taken his career backwards?

 

Enough? Enough to watch his brothers career ruined by the same bloke/club?

 

Enough? Enough to accept shite like Jeff fucking Hendrick signed and played over him?

 

Enough? Enough to have told Bruce the truth about how shite he is, only for Bruce to ostracise him AND his brother?

 

Enough? Fuck that. The bloke and his whole family have probably had just about enough already tbf.

[Yorkie]

First twenty odd pages of this thread make quite a depressing flick-through. So much optimism.